GWD-13-17

yukon

Guild members could make

and sell women’s and chil-

dren’s clothing, but were

prohibited from producing

           men’s clothing or dresses

           for court women.

文中只说不许买 men’s clothing or dresses给court women，没说不许卖衣服给court women啊! 其它类型的衣服照样可以卖给court women

我觉得17题的A不对

remona9t

2楼解释得很精彩！明白了！~

xinfaxian

以下是引用IceOnMe在2005-5-28 15:46:00的发言：

对于17题,我认为是A

首先,

be restricted to do A  是某人被限制只能做A

restriction on A = 做A的限制       金山的例句:

The restrictions on the use of the playground are:no fighting, no damaging property.
使用这场地的条件是:不准打架, 不准损坏设施。

意义完全不一样

接着分析一下文中句子

meanwhile, were impatient with the remaining restrictions on their right to clothe women.

重新分析一下这句. 我的理解是 "女裁缝们对给妇女做衣服这个权利上残余的限制感到impatient." 也就是说女裁缝们被给予了权利,(冲破了一定的限制)但这个权利中依然有限制

显然,这个restriction是被限定在为妇女做衣服的权利这个范围之内了,

那什么是remaining restriction呢, 显然就是不能为court women做衣服(即非所有的妇女)

如果要把剩余的限制解释为 不能为男人做衣服,

相当于把这句话:

The restrictions on the use of the playground are:no fighting, no damaging property.
使用这场地的条件是:不准打架, 不准损坏设施。

理解成 限制使用该场地

所以我认为要表达对"不能做男人衣服的不满"这个意思,则文中应该出现类似的句子:

they were impatient with the restriction to their right to (only) clothe women.

they were impatient that they were still be restricted to clothe women.

所以17不应该是B

精彩！

wwwhahchn

同意BADA

这篇的生词把我害惨了，感觉很影响理解，错了2个

PKGMAT

17题一不小心就看成了是女裁缝不满意把其限制在只能作妇女的衣服上。其实原文是讲妇裁缝不满意对其作妇女的衣服都仍有限制。不过前文已经交待了这点，只是现场作题一急就忘了。看来还是逻辑语感建立得不够强，很容易就掉进了ETS的陷井中。

dreamerps

19T的题干中有个词是primarily,那么B中的conflict最根本上是为了说明什么？不就是为了说明A中的were not solely economic吗？也就是二段一句，这是全文的TS啊，对应16T主题题看正确选想B：summarize sources of conflict between...,所以从primarily的角度出发19T应该选A，B是为了说明A，我一看到primarily就引起重视了，这是我的理解，欢迎指教~~

nyc_cfa

T-4-10:GWD-13-18:

It can be inferred from the passage that which of the following was true of seamstresses employed by relatives who were members of the tailors’ guild?

              

1. They were instrumental in convincing Louis XIV to establish the seamstresses’ guild.



2. They were rarely allowed to assist master tailors in the production of men’s clothing.



3. They were considered by some tailors to be a threat to the tailors’ monopoly.



4. They did not enjoy the same economic and legal privileges that members of the seamstresses’ guild enjoyed.



5. They felt their status as working women gave them a certain degree of independence from the patriarchal family.

应该是E. 文中没有提到D.

Febby1984

我觉得18T中的那个THEY FELT很诡异,文章就没有说到那些被TAILOR雇佣的女性的感受啊~

19T,我怎么觉得A.B都不对啊~首先A里面的establishment of the seamstresses' guild had implication...就不对~并不是行会的建立暗示了什么;

但是B里面的conflict over membership in tailors' guild肯定错,文中说的是conflict over memvership in guild's, 这里的GUILD应该是包含tailors' and seamstresses'

keys~~

amy9301

tangela

对于我这类没什么逻辑只凭直觉的文科生，是如此弱滴解释１７题地：

对于Ｂ选项：女裁缝不是不满男裁缝可以做男人衣服，而是不满自己不能做男人衣服（要注意这２点是不一样的哦）

哈哈．．．非常弱的解释，不过自我感觉应该是这样吧．．．

看了ＮＮ们的解释真是觉得严谨才是硬道理～

以上