GWD-13-17

blackpalms

#19

I think the error in choice B is "THE CONFLICT BETWEEN TAILORS AND THEIR FEMALE FAMILY MEMBERS."

At the conflict’s center was

the issue of whether tailors’

female relatives should be

identified as family members

(50)      protected by the tailors’ guild

or as individuals under the

jurisdiction of the seam-

stresses’ guild.

We can see from this sentence that the actual conflict is between whether the female family member of the tailors should be in the TAILOR'S GUILD or in SEAMSTRESSES' GUILD.

Chice D says that the conflict is between the FEMALE FAMILY MEMBERS OF THE TAILORS and the TAILORS. No where in the passage mentioned there is a conflict between the two parties picked by Choice D.

Although the conflict of which guild do the female family members belong existed, there is no conflict between female family members and tailors.

thanx and open to discussion  ^_^

fair_sword

以下是引用caterpillar在2004-8-17 0:45:00的发言：

这个好象应该是common sense吧，女裁缝不许做，要是男裁缝也不许做的话，男人都穿什么呀？：）况且，这里明显表达的意思是：以前是所有衣服都归男裁缝做，现在女裁缝可以做女人和孩子的衣服了。

17题我还是觉得选B更好，当然主要还是在于对这句话的理解：were impatient with the remaining restrictions on their right to clothe women.我觉得这句话的意思是：对于仍然限制她们只许做女人的衣服表示不耐烦。

男人可以自己做呀，嘿嘿！我这是抬杠了

现在觉得B对，同意

当然主要还是在于对这句话的理解：were impatient with the remaining restrictions on their right to clothe women.我觉得这句话的意思是：对于仍然限制她们只许做女人的衣服表示不耐烦。

crazyep

16)

The primary purpose of the passage is to

              

1. outline a scholarly debate over the impact of the Parisian seamstresses’ guild
2. summarize sources of conflict between the newly created Parisian seamstresses’ guild and the tailors’ guild

3. describe opposing views concerning the origins of the Parisian seamstresses’ guild

4. explore the underlying reasons for establishing an exclusively female guild in seventeenth-century Paris

5. correct a misconception about changes in seamstresses’ economic status that took place in Paris in the late seventeenth century

16题大家都没什么疑问么？ 为什么选B？newly created 明显是错的呀。

我选的的是D。“underlying reasons”  is same with “scource and confilcts”

horsefish

17我选B,

A 中的sell文章里没提过, 只说不能做某类的, 没说不能卖

sofarsgood

A 中的sell文章里没提过, 只说不能做某类的, 没说不能卖

seamstresses, meanwhile, were remaining restrictions on their right to clothe women.

我觉得这里clothe 把make和sell都包括了。mm你看呢？

horsefish

以下是引用sofarsgood在2004-9-23 11:15:00的发言：

A 中的sell文章里没提过, 只说不能做某类的, 没说不能卖

seamstresses, meanwhile, were remaining restrictions on their right to clothe women.

我觉得这里clothe 把make和sell都包括了。mm你看呢？

还是认为是做衣服不是卖衣服:cloth:做动词是提供衣服, 做衣服, 不是卖衣服.

leeon

17题，想了半天，还是同意A。

B中的最主要错误是tailors这个放大了范围。clothe women应该包含了make和sell了。那个时候应该还不像现在这样有那么多专卖店、商场，那时候买衣服应该是去找裁缝来作的。

comeby_j2004

以下是引用醋醋妹妹在2004-7-13 3:00:00的发言：

be restricted on --- 对...有限制

be restricted to --- 仅限制于做...

were impatient with the remaining restrictions on their right to clothe women是指对做妇女的衣服有限制(你能做女人的衣服, 但不是所有的, 比如说宫廷贵妇的衣服你就不能做)

文中的impatient与问题中的dissatification对应, 偶选A.

court women比例少不少, 与答题不相关且文中未提到.

我觉得要是理解成对做妇女的衣服有限制的话，那是不是应该用 the remaining restrictions on their right in clothing women, 而不是to, 既然用to, 可能还是不满意不能为男人做衣服吧。

tiantian

我也不明白16的B，我选A， 当然debate好象也不对。可是B中的the newly creat实在是离谱的说。

The primary purpose of the passage is to

              

1. outline a scholarly debate over the impact of the Parisian seamstresses’ guild
2. summarize sources of conflict between the newly created Parisian seamstresses’ guild and the tailors’ guild
   
3. describe opposing views concerning the origins of the Parisian seamstresses’ guild

4. explore the underlying reasons for establishing an exclusively female guild in seventeenth-century Paris

5. correct a misconception about changes in seamstresses’ economic status that took place in Paris in the late seventeenth century

tulipmontreal

17 A

19 B