我有Research Potential!

kejinghuhou

楼主如果在美国读了三年经济学博士并且过了qualifier的话，应该有基本的研究素养，知道文章好坏和期刊好坏的呀。怎么感觉楼主这么二。。。。。。小弱啥都不懂，随口乱说的。。。。

if you didn't publish anything, people don't know whether you are good or bad and may still believe you have the potential. but since you published a B paper, people will judge you on this by thinking you don't have potential to publish on A journal.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/25 20:28:09)

晕，这是啥逻辑啊

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/25 20:41:16)

你读了3年econ的phd连最简单的bayesian learning都不懂？

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/10/25 21:22:36)

晕，bayesian expectation theory没这么说啊。
如果signal比mean高的话，这个signal还是有好处的啊。
难道这个杂志这么差，连average都不到吗？
至少也有了十几年的历史了啊。

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/26 9:25:43)

cookie_jie

哈哈，我来打酱油，只是觉得LZ好可爱啊，说话一惊一乍的。。。

dhatura999

总有那么多自己比较2的人到处满嘴喷粪。。。。。。

楼主如果在美国读了三年经济学博士并且过了qualifier的话，应该有基本的研究素养，知道文章好坏和期刊好坏的呀。怎么感觉楼主这么二。。。。。。小弱啥都不懂，随口乱说的。。。。

if you didn't publish anything, people don't know whether you are good or bad and may still believe you have the potential. but since you published a B paper, people will judge you on this by thinking you don't have potential to publish on A journal.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/25 20:28:09)

晕，这是啥逻辑啊

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/25 20:41:16)

你读了3年econ的phd连最简单的bayesian learning都不懂？

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/10/25 21:22:36)

晕，bayesian expectation theory没这么说啊。
如果signal比mean高的话，这个signal还是有好处的啊。
难道这个杂志这么差，连average都不到吗？
至少也有了十几年的历史了啊。

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/26 9:25:43)

-- by 会员 kejinghuhou (2012/10/27 3:21:16)

zzmypster

if you published a B journal, say, JEP, i think that might help. But this journal may not be counted as even a C.  Having said this, you will also need to consider LZ's previous 3-year econ phd background.  people will have a much higher expectation on LZ given her Phd background.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/26 10:02:02)

Journal of Economic Perspectives? That's not peer-reviewed. Most (if not all) of the papers there are by invitation. As a application, it is possible to have top 5 but definitely not JEP or JEL.

dhatura999

哈哈，我来打酱油，只是觉得LZ好可爱啊，说话一惊一乍的。。。

-- by 会员 cookie_jie (2012/10/27 5:18:01)

晕，又被人批评说话一惊一乍的。。。。。。
心情比较激动，哈哈
这个vailed criticism我接受，呵呵

dhatura999

if you published a B journal, say, JEP, i think that might help. But this journal may not be counted as even a C.  Having said this, you will also need to consider LZ's previous 3-year econ phd background.  people will have a much higher expectation on LZ given her Phd background.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/26 10:02:02)

Journal of Economic Perspectives? That's not peer-reviewed. Most (if not all) of the papers there are by invitation. As a application, it is possible to have top 5 but definitely not JEP or JEL.

-- by 会员 zzmypster (2012/10/27 9:10:15)

As a application, it is possible to have top 5。。。。。
看来还是需要努力啊。。。。。。

dhatura999

有b还是比没有强。
但lz发的这种估计连d有没有都成问题的……还是别提了吧

-- by 会员 zzmypster (2012/10/26 2:35:14)

我决定还是提一下。
我觉得有发表说明我有research interest。
我可以说这个期刊不是我的target，
我希望能在老师的指导下和同行的帮助下写出更好的论文。。。。。。

kejinghuhou

我都说了我啥都不懂....楼主还这么说我.....

总有那么多自己比较2的人到处满嘴喷粪。。。。。。

楼主如果在美国读了三年经济学博士并且过了qualifier的话，应该有基本的研究素养，知道文章好坏和期刊好坏的呀。怎么感觉楼主这么二。。。。。。小弱啥都不懂，随口乱说的。。。。

if you didn't publish anything, people don't know whether you are good or bad and may still believe you have the potential. but since you published a B paper, people will judge you on this by thinking you don't have potential to publish on A journal.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/25 20:28:09)

晕，这是啥逻辑啊

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/25 20:41:16)

你读了3年econ的phd连最简单的bayesian learning都不懂？

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/10/25 21:22:36)

晕，bayesian expectation theory没这么说啊。
如果signal比mean高的话，这个signal还是有好处的啊。
难道这个杂志这么差，连average都不到吗？
至少也有了十几年的历史了啊。

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/26 9:25:43)

-- by 会员 kejinghuhou (2012/10/27 3:21:16)

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/27 8:55:45)

jangle

lz的id为何我看起来总感觉像老印的名字

dhatura999

你啥都不懂，就可以随口骂我2的吗？

我都说了我啥都不懂....楼主还这么说我.....

总有那么多自己比较2的人到处满嘴喷粪。。。。。。

楼主如果在美国读了三年经济学博士并且过了qualifier的话，应该有基本的研究素养，知道文章好坏和期刊好坏的呀。怎么感觉楼主这么二。。。。。。小弱啥都不懂，随口乱说的。。。。

if you didn't publish anything, people don't know whether you are good or bad and may still believe you have the potential. but since you published a B paper, people will judge you on this by thinking you don't have potential to publish on A journal.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/25 20:28:09)

晕，这是啥逻辑啊

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/25 20:41:16)

你读了3年econ的phd连最简单的bayesian learning都不懂？

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/10/25 21:22:36)

晕，bayesian expectation theory没这么说啊。
如果signal比mean高的话，这个signal还是有好处的啊。
难道这个杂志这么差，连average都不到吗？
至少也有了十几年的历史了啊。

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/26 9:25:43)

-- by 会员 kejinghuhou (2012/10/27 3:21:16)

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/27 8:55:45)

-- by 会员 kejinghuhou (2012/10/27 11:59:04)