我有Research Potential!

marku

所以说还是别误导了， 有A 还读 phd干啥，直接找交织的了， 如果还是单独发表的话

zzmypster

有b还是比没有强。
但lz发的这种估计连d有没有都成问题的……还是别提了吧

judydong

可以当成writing sample吧，写的出完整的paper已经比很多刚开始读的人强了

其实jj也不用纠结了吧，反正要去读的，有或者没有何必现在计较，不如多读几片paper

dhatura999

if you didn't publish anything, people don't know whether you are good or bad and may still believe you have the potential. but since you published a B paper, people will judge you on this by thinking you don't have potential to publish on A journal.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/25 20:28:09)

晕，这是啥逻辑啊

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/25 20:41:16)

你读了3年econ的phd连最简单的bayesian learning都不懂？

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/10/25 21:22:36)

晕，bayesian expectation theory没这么说啊。
如果signal比mean高的话，这个signal还是有好处的啊。
难道这个杂志这么差，连average都不到吗？
至少也有了十几年的历史了啊。

accprof

if you published a B journal, say, JEP, i think that might help. But this journal may not be counted as even a C.  Having said this, you will also need to consider LZ's previous 3-year econ phd background.  people will have a much higher expectation on LZ given her Phd background.

dhatura999

if you published a B journal, say, JEP, i think that might help. But this journal may not be counted as even a C.  Having said this, you will also need to consider LZ's previous 3-year econ phd background.  people will have a much higher expectation on LZ given her Phd background.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/26 10:02:02)

你们这么说让我觉得我的paper有点明珠暗投了，呵呵

kndx5

if you didn't publish anything, people don't know whether you are good or bad and may still believe you have the potential. but since you published a B paper, people will judge you on this by thinking you don't have potential to publish on A journal.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/25 20:28:09)

晕，这是啥逻辑啊

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/25 20:41:16)

你读了3年econ的phd连最简单的bayesian learning都不懂？

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/10/25 21:22:36)

晕，bayesian expectation theory没这么说啊。
如果signal比mean高的话，这个signal还是有好处的啊。
难道这个杂志这么差，连average都不到吗？
至少也有了十几年的历史了啊。

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/26 9:25:43)

average表示被鄙视了。。。。。

dhatura999

晕，是我的论文被鄙视了，而我不久前还为它被发表了很excited，呵呵

marku

if you published a B journal, say, JEP, i think that might help. But this journal may not be counted as even a C.  Having said this, you will also need to consider LZ's previous 3-year econ phd background.  people will have a much higher expectation on LZ given her Phd background.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/26 10:02:02)

are you kidding?? JEP might help?? JEP is better than CAR!

accprof

in acc, CAR is counted as top 5, but JEP is not.  in econ, JEP is a (leading) B journal.