我有Research Potential!

accprof

老师说发个B以下的反而不好

-- by 会员 oo7 (2012/10/25 3:23:46)

在大多数情况下，对的

dhatura999

老师说发个B以下的反而不好

-- by 会员 oo7 (2012/10/25 3:23:46)

在大多数情况下，对的

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/25 8:06:25)

这个的rationale是啥？

jacquiline

Status signals (see Podolny, 2005)

accprof

if you didn't publish anything, people don't know whether you are good or bad and may still believe you have the potential. but since you published a B paper, people will judge you on this by thinking you don't have potential to publish on A journal.

dhatura999

if you didn't publish anything, people don't know whether you are good or bad and may still believe you have the potential. but since you published a B paper, people will judge you on this by thinking you don't have potential to publish on A journal.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/25 20:28:09)

晕，这是啥逻辑啊

Zingales

if you didn't publish anything, people don't know whether you are good or bad and may still believe you have the potential. but since you published a B paper, people will judge you on this by thinking you don't have potential to publish on A journal.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/25 20:28:09)

晕，这是啥逻辑啊

-- by 会员 dhatura999 (2012/10/25 20:41:16)

你读了3年econ的phd连最简单的bayesian learning都不懂？

marku

纯粹误导，说发b不好的人， 你们自己发了什么啊， D？ 还是连d 都不如？？

fzxc613

B is fine, as long as it is not a C.

fzxc613

if you didn't publish anything, people don't know whether you are good or bad and may still believe you have the potential. but since you published a B paper, people will judge you on this by thinking you don't have potential to publish on A journal.

-- by 会员 accprof (2012/10/25 20:28:09)

That's very ture

marku

for those who wants to apply phd, owing nothing is better than owing a b journal publication???