GWD-9-39

流沙

我觉得c的平行不是最重要的。d在句意上是正确的，不能单独看power in germany。

又想起一点，whereas也是要求能平行就平行的。d看起来是最平行的

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-9-27 9:02:00编辑过]

携隐

汗~~~,第2次做这道题,居然想了半天选了D......不记得为什么我第一次在第一时间就觉得in Germany有问题了.从平行上看,D好像更好.不过我觉得ETS比较喜欢用C的这种主动形式.

对本题答案疑惑中......

dream1111

以下是引用流沙在2004-9-27 0:04:00的发言：

我觉得c的平行不是最重要的。d在句意上是正确的，不能单独看power in germany。

又想起一点，whereas也是要求能平行就平行的。d看起来是最平行的

I do not agree that 'd在句意上是正确的',     ' in germany' is wrongly placed .

read it again.

rings

其实A怎么不对?不是更加简洁嘛?

linxi8389

严重同意楼上

sunshining

以下是引用rings在2004-10-10 12:55:00的发言：
其实A怎么不对?不是更加简洁嘛?

allwen99

以下是引用sunshining在2004-10-27 1:36:00的发言：

it 指代什麼呢? 若是代 energy, 則意義不完整. 完整的應代 energy derives from nuclear power,

但 it無法如此指代, 所以 A 錯.

to be discussed...

薰衣紫草

C

I really wish I could imput Chinese to translate it. Unfortunately, I don't. Let's put it this way.

The intolerable flaw in D is that it disorts the meaning of the original sentence. The first half of the orginal sentence says that among the energy produced in France, 75% of it comes from nuclear power. The sentence then makes a comparison that in Germany, over 33% of the energy produced comes from nuclear power. But when you look at D, it's trying to say that IN FRANCE, over 33% of the energy comes from neclear power in German, another contry. When we check if the format is parallel, more important thing is to make sure if it's logically consistent.

Open to discussion

ruin

楼上的解释很有道理，严重支持C

爱维的天

对啦!
18楼的熏衣紫草对﹙D﹚的句意作清楚的解释
﹙D﹚whereas just over 33 percent of the energy comes from nuclear power in Germany
这个选项扭曲的原意
表地方的状语的位置是很重要的，D把in Germany这个状语放在nuclear power之后，说明了只有33%的能源来自在德国的核电厂，那表示还有其它66%的能源来自其它国家啰!这和原句意义不同。

﹙C﹚whereas nuclear power accounts for just over 33 percent of the energy produced in Germany
﹙C﹚表达了在德国制造的能源中，核电能源占了的33%，表示了其它66%来自其它能源。这和未划线部分的意义是相同的。

而且﹙C﹚比﹙D﹚较和未划线部分平行，虽然我也支持流沙说的—平行不是最重要的。

应该是﹙C﹚