GWD Set 12 T19

tendgrr

不知现在大家什么看法？？有NN吗

zxzhyzcy

从头到尾把讨论看了２遍

决定选Ｃ

撇开has...in the past不谈

Ｅ的being是多余的！（且不论它缺不缺乏主语！）one that 同位语重复

Ｃ虽然指代远了一点，但是不存在逻辑和语法错误

虽然刚开始做题的时候觉得miss signs of incipient trouble or misinterpret them when they do appear两个动作需要区分，但是仔细想想，不管是miss还是misinterpret都可以发生在they do appear的情况下，因此分开说是重复的，所以Ｃ在这一点上也是对的

lloottuuss

选E吧。既然找到原始出处了。

ligaoping

这道题语法区常见的几个大牛都没有发表意见，不知是什么原因。不会是因为太简单了吧？！

我原来是选C，但是当时就对原句中miss signs of incipient trouble or misinterpret them when they do appear改成C中的miss or misinterpret signs of incipient trouble when they do appear心存芥蒂。incipient本身就有刚刚出现的这层含义，后面再加上when they do appear是否语义有重复呢？另外原句中动词make随意换成其他动词是不是可以呢？前面大家都没有讨论这二个问题。哪个NN可以解释一下吗？

谢谢

wsdoll

以下是引用ligaoping在2007-8-12 1:01:00的发言：

这道题语法区常见的几个大牛都没有发表意见，不知是什么原因。不会是因为太简单了吧？！

我原来是选C，但是当时就对原句中miss signs of incipient trouble or misinterpret them when they do appear改成C中的miss or misinterpret signs of incipient trouble when they do appear心存芥蒂。incipient本身就有刚刚出现的这层含义，后面再加上when they do appear是否语义有重复呢？另外原句中动词make随意换成其他动词是不是可以呢？前面大家都没有讨论这二个问题。哪个NN可以解释一下吗？

谢谢

good point

更说明了选E. C中的这样改法是错误的。

Hamiton

    

"n., one that.. " is redunant, because one is sufficient to introduce the modifer... (from OG explanation); so E is not right.

9.
Astronomers at the Palomar Observatory have discovered a distant supernova
explosion, one that they believe is a type previously unknown to
science.

    

(A)   that they
believe is

    

(B)    that they
believe it to be

    

(C)   they
believe that it is of

    

(D)   they
believe that is

    

(E)    they
believe to be of

    
Choice E is best. The pronoun that in A and B should be deleted,
since the pronoun one is sufficient to introduce the modifier and the
sentence is more fluid without that.
    

tangzimo

C

矬子里拨大个儿了

C的it指代确实不明……

CloseToU

顶一下 E

不能因为ETS不喜欢用Being就说它不对

四个选项都有问题，相对来说，E是最好的选项了

aircavalry

C最大的问题就是句子重心被改变了

szdmm

being done : as subject
example:
prep 1 /103: being genetically engineered does not make a plant any more likely to ----

one : refers to singular noun mentioned before it.

in C, "it" is too far from a course of action & "it " usually refers to the same one mentioned, so it is not appropriate to use "it" here.