[求助]GWD-17-9

coffemug

先开始和SHAOHELI想的一模一样,但仔细看才知道其实是反方案"不"认为第三方审计是公正的,这样一来就对原文没有帮助了.  所以还是选B.   我觉得用集合图能帮助理解.  拙见.

mko

the key words are " the scheduled highway projects"

lxzjojo

明白鸟！B的关键字其实是那个scheduled highway projects，也就是决定要执行的项目！与文中的canceled projects联系起来就会想明白啦！

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-11-2 15:25:12编辑过]

boochxu

ding

panglin

ding......

boochxu

ding

LOUI1121

MY OPINION:

LETS USE LAWYERS WAY OF SOLVING THIS QUESTION(USING THE SUPPORT, I.E. THERE IS A GAP). REINTERPRET THE ARGUMENT AS BELOW:

1.90% PROJECTS CANCELLED WERE IN DISTRICTS CONTROLLED BY OPPOSITE PARTY --> PRESIDENT CANCELLATION WAS UNFAIR.

2.CANCELLATION PROJECTS WERE IDENTIFIED AS WASTEFUL IN THE REPORT --> PRESIDENTS CANCELLATION WAS FAIR.

THE GAP THEN IS BETWEEN :

1.DISTRICTS CONTROLLED BY SOME PARTY

2.CANCELLED PROJECTS IDENTIFIED AS WASTEFUL IN THE REPORT.

SO CONNECT ABOVE 2 POINTS UP, IS THE ANSWER B.

E)CHOICE IS HERE TO CONFUSE US. WHEN WE FINISH READING THE PASSAGE ,WE WOULD THINK THAT THE REPORT BY NON-BIASED PEOPLE IS ACUTALLY BIASED. SO WITHOUT CLOST AT IT, WE WOULD CHOOSE E). HOWEVER, LIKE PEOPLE HAVE SAID, E)IS ONLY OPINION FROM THE OPPOSITE PARTY,AFTER NEGATION,  DOES NOT WEAKEN THE ARGUMENT.

I CHOSED E) WHEN I FIRST DID THE QUESTION.

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-1-22 17:50:59编辑过]

abort

B
反对党认为总统实行partisan politics，论据是取消的项目当中有90％都属于反对党管辖的区，Secretary的论点是总统实行budgetary policy，论据是所有取消的项目都是因为无党派人士的报告认为那些项目是wasteful的，言下之意就是在无党派报告中认为是wasteful的项目中有90％都是反对党的项目（相当于B），而B取非的话就是无党派报告中认为是wasteful的项目大部分是总统所在的党派所管辖的地区，那么结论将是总统是partison pollitics，因为总统包庇了自己的党派，punish了反对党