OG13-48 玩电脑的孩子不与人交流这题求教与讨论

cutelotus

48. Although computers can enhance people's abilityto communicate, computer games are a cause of underdeveloped communicationskills in children. After-school hours spent playing computer games are hoursnot spent talking with people. Therefore, children who spend all their sparetime playing these games have less experience in interpersonal communicationthan other children have.

The argument depends on which of the following assumptions?

(A) Passive activities such as watching television and listening to music donot hinder the development of communication skills in children.
(B) Most children have other opportunities, in addition to after-school hours,in which they can choose whether to play computer games or to interact withother people.
(C) Children who do not spend all of their after-school hours playing computergames spend at least some of that time talking with other people.
(D) Formal instruction contributes little or nothing to children's acquisitionof communication skills.
(E) The mental skills developed through playing computer games do notcontribute significantly to children's intellectual development.

这题选C，我选错了，而且看了很多之前帖子的解释，仍然不解，不太理解为什么要“取非“，在什么情况下”取非“？

我的理解：从答案出发，那就是Children who do not spend all of their after-school hours playing computer games spend at least some of that time talking with other people.是children who spend all their spare time playing these games have less experience in interpersonal communication than other children have的assumption----------思前想后这中间有什么必然的逻辑联系么？好像没有吧？如果硬说有也相当牵强吧？         还请各位大侠不吝赐教~~~

南蛮也爱球

你们做题都得讲所谓的逻辑结构嘛？

cutelotus

南蛮也爱球 发表于 2014-3-3 18:06
你们做题都得讲所谓的逻辑结构嘛？

??然后呢

南蛮也爱球

觉得gwd的说法不错，逻辑尽量直来直去

cutelotus

cutelotus 发表于 2014-3-4 16:43
??然后呢

好吧 谢谢了

theory

说一说我的想法。
这道题首先把因果关系找一下。
玩游戏的时候=不跟别人说话的时候。因此，把所有时间用来玩游戏的孩子会比不把所有时间用来玩游戏的孩子与人交流的更少。

真正使孩子们与别人交流减少的原因是“不跟别人说话”，玩游戏是导致“不跟别人说话”的原因之一。 不想跟别人说话也可以成为“不跟别人说话”的原因。

因此题目结论中，隐含着”不玩游戏的孩子都是会跟别人说话的孩子“这样的假设

不知可否帮到楼主

奔奔宝贝

theory 发表于 2014-3-25 16:32
说一说我的想法。
这道题首先把因果关系找一下。
玩游戏的时候=不跟别人说话的时候。因此，把所有时间用来 ...

难道theory也学了helr的逻辑分类方法，可否交流下？

theory

奔奔宝贝 发表于 2014-3-25 19:56
难道theory也学了helr的逻辑分类方法，可否交流下？

没有学过。。。不过很欢迎交流，共同进步嘛

奔奔宝贝

theory 发表于 2014-3-25 19:58
没有学过。。。不过很欢迎交流，共同进步嘛

我有一些关于helr逻辑分类的疑问，你要是没学过就不好交流了。对了，你什么时候考？

theory

奔奔宝贝 发表于 2014-3-25 20:08
我有一些关于helr逻辑分类的疑问，你要是没学过就不好交流了。对了，你什么时候考？ ...

4月23。之前考过砸了。。。。