Kellogg Or Wharton for Finance PhD

kndx5

就marketing的faculty以及phd program来讲,wharton拉kellogg十几条街呢,kellogg的marketing也就是mba名气很大,搞的很多人都觉得kellogg的marketing是no.1.其实kellogg的behavior还不错,modeling就差一些, 也就是个10名左右的水平,前几年连像样的faculty都招不到,搞得还得从他们managerial econ的candidate里面去找.

wharton和kellogg我觉得总体各有千秋学校。不过wharton的Acct我觉得比Kellogg明显好。和kellogg相比wharton差的应该是Applied Econ（一个凑到一起的program）。Marketing应该也是Kellogg强吧。不过Wharton的stats很牛的。

其实wharton应该是一个金融著称的学校，本来应该有一个相当于MIT，斯坦福的PhD program。觉得去wharton visit的人也都比Duke，UCLA，Columbia和Kellogg强。把自己的program整成这样真实可惜了“Wharton”这个名字了。

-- by 会员 Mengsk (2011/4/8 15:25:07)

pitty111

是啊Dye今年又有一个拉美学生去了stanford～～要说care学生的analytical accounting faculty，还有Minnesota啊～Kanodia大哥带那么多牛人出来～～ABC和Chinese完全两码子事。甚至本科在美国名校念的和在大陆念的也完全不在一个起跑线上，前者americanize很多，完全non-comparable.看placements还是要看清楚啊。像Wharton今年那个Clare Wang, 很shining的简历。没名校under degreee的Chinese，羡慕嫉妒恨就好，要达到那个水平真的几乎不可能。

做theory还是Kellogg好，Ron Dye的学生不是去Columbia, Harvard就是去Stanford, Verecchia貌似这么多年就带了个Kim出来。 Empirical也看人，Kellogg的非中国人也有place到Chicago, MIT的，不过话说回来今年Wharton的一个ABC去了Kellogg

呵呵,finance还能纠结一下,acc kellogg和wharton比差距太大了吧

我会选kellogg，因为刚从wharton visit回来，和finance的几个人聊了一下，性格上不是很合适。。。

-- by 会员 jingzhimeng (2011/4/8 0:21:11)

-- by 会员 kndx5 (2011/4/8 2:30:35)

-- by 会员 majia20112011 (2011/4/8 10:27:07)

kndx5

呵呵,你去问问随便哪个做modeling的faculty,看看他们谁会觉得kellogg的model能和wharton一个档次. yuxin 作的非常好,但是根raju也不是一个重量级的吧, anderson这两年paper发的还行,但是跟bradlow也比不了吧,除了他俩你在kellogg还能找出像样的作modeling的senior了吗???wharton大把大把的modeling faculty,都作的不错, 讲说当年song yao要是有wharton的offer也不会去kellogg了. 说到排名,modeling chicago肯定比wharton好, mit难说,剩下的真找不出比wharton好的了, 而mba elite 7里面, kellogg的marketing modeling应该是最弱的, 剩下还有nyu,duke, berkeley,前两个肯定比kellogg好,berkeley至少不比kellogg差, 所以说kellogg排到10名左右一点也不委屈他.

就marketing的faculty以及phd program来讲,wharton拉kellogg十几条街呢,kellogg的marketing也就是mba名气很大,搞的很多人都觉得kellogg的marketing是no.1.其实kellogg的behavior还不错,modeling就差一些, 也就是个10名左右的水平,前几年连像样的faculty都招不到,搞得还得从他们managerial econ的candidate里面去找.
by 会员 kndx5 (2011/4/8 20:25:09)

谁说kellogg quant不如wharton了？Wharton现在也就是Fader and Bradlow的天下。Kellogg 也有 Anderson, Chen Yuxin 等一批中坚力量，和Song Yao (I think he's going to get  tenure there) 等新生代马。Quant placement wise 两个学校差不多呀。

-- by 会员 anakinsky (2011/4/8 21:30:46)

kndx5

或者这么说,如果有wharton marketing的offer你会不会去kellogg,你的答案就能说明你是不是真的觉得kellogg跟wharton差不多.

就marketing的faculty以及phd program来讲,wharton拉kellogg十几条街呢,kellogg的marketing也就是mba名气很大,搞的很多人都觉得kellogg的marketing是no.1.其实kellogg的behavior还不错,modeling就差一些, 也就是个10名左右的水平,前几年连像样的faculty都招不到,搞得还得从他们managerial econ的candidate里面去找.
by 会员 kndx5 (2011/4/8 20:25:09)

谁说kellogg quant不如wharton了？Wharton现在也就是Fader and Bradlow的天下。Kellogg 也有 Anderson, Chen Yuxin 等一批中坚力量，和Song Yao (I think he's going to get  tenure there) 等新生代马。Quant placement wise 两个学校差不多呀。

-- by 会员 anakinsky (2011/4/8 21:30:46)

Mengsk

I dont know anything about marketing. But the reason why I made this statement (misconception) is that a friend of my is turning down Wharton for Kellogg in quant marketing (also someone on the other forum). I think both have something to do with the faculty there being cold.

kndx5

actually, marketing faculty at wharton are very helpful and nice, they advertise their students when the students are on the market, which is opposite to chicago, that is why, from what i know, some students turn down chicago to wharton. I guess your friend does not know a lot about quant marketing but chooses kellogg over wharton just because kellogg marketing has big name in its MBA program.

I dont know anything about marketing. But the reason why I made this statement (misconception) is that a friend of my is turning down Wharton for Kellogg in quant marketing (also someone on the other forum). I think both have something to do with the faculty there being cold.

-- by 会员 Mengsk (2011/4/8 23:07:45)

edog

Mengsk, out of curiosity - how were NYU / Columbia placements this year? I know NYU had one star (Xavier Giroud) this year, but what about the others?

cnrnld

金融上，沃顿基本上就是头一排了。

slmytdp

请教一下CLARE WANG牛在何处？非抬杠，纯好奇，这种IBD混了6年的申PHD觉得蛮奇怪的。

majia20112011

Clare is a very good presenter. Her job market paper is innovative in her field though her addressing question is not fantastic, especially for questions related to the model part of her paper. She loves school so she went for a PhD.

请教一下CLARE WANG牛在何处？非抬杠，纯好奇，这种IBD混了6年的申PHD觉得蛮奇怪的。

-- by 会员 slmytdp (2011/4/12 23:57:32)