Duke和INSEAD，选择哪个offer?迷茫中。。。

ddtt

以下是引用kinchan在2007-3-12 21:24:00的发言：

乔治同学,我同意你关于INSEAD的finance的评论,但这不足以论证"If you wanna go to IB, go for duke".请提供数据说明Duke的finance不sucks

同问！

robinst

learnt a lot...

en...esp...mind my words in case i would step on someone's nerve...

This world is dangerous...

by the way, lz

if you want to work in the states, go duke...

i guess u hv a plan for yourself?

then why it's so hard to decide coz this two schools hv lots of differences...

eeyupyup

以下是引用fienfde在2007-3-9 15:13:00的发言：

同时拿到了Duke和INSEAD的offer，但是也就开始了困惑。。。

本人今年32岁了，INSEAD的Global ranking更牛，学制短08年毕业，但是秋季学期没有Intern的机会，而且欧洲的工作机会很少。。。

Duke就要09年毕业，在美国是不是工作机会更好找呢

其实本人最希望毕业后找个好工作能回北京或者上海，从毕业后工作的角度，请大家帮助参谋哪个offer更好？谢谢啦。。。

Insead

why do you care 欧洲的工作机会很少, if you plan to 找个好工作能回北京或者上海?

I dont think Insead has a less-presitage name in asia. 1 year short in school means you will have one more year to work and and progress your career. (some money saving too) 33/34 is kinda old to break into IB, not to mention niether school is known for its finance program. And if you want a MC job, Insead is just as good as Duke.

goodluck

Huangzizeng

楼上说的对啊,insead比哈佛都牛啊.

而且据说老师也很强,不是一个档次的.

ddtt

以下是引用sinocheetah在2007-3-10 0:42:00的发言：

After I interviewed by Joewu, a Duke alumni from Shanghai, I have a very bad impression of Duke MBA. Later I got a Darden alumni interview, the guy was much much more friendly and helpful than Duke one. I appreciated his effort even I may get denial from Darden.

Actually there are so many Chinese students in Duke MBA, and I found the Duke alumni in Shanghai is so so...

这个要反驳你.

虽然我最后也不一定去DUKE

不能因为某个校友的问题就说学校不好.

面我的DUKE校友就非常NICE,非常SMART.

ddtt

以下是引用sinocheetah在2007-3-10 10:19:00的发言：

I never ruin the reputation of Duke and just tell the truth. Duke is quite good in my mind.

But when landing a job in AP region, you have to compete with more people with similar backgrounds. Duke has around 40, INSEAD(one intake) has around 15 Chinese.

I have to remind you INSEAD has no non-cosigner loan. You may have to finance yourself,but it provides most Chinese students some scholarship from 8K to 20K euros.

g7m5a0t: i never attempt to use any offensive words in my post. would you be more rational and peaceful? young age will not justify the rudeness!

DUKE的每年的中国学生也就20个左右

录了40人,不是所有人都会去.俺觉得是DUKE厚道,发的OFFER多.她也完全可以WL很多人，再逐个发OFFER,很多学校都是这么干的,为了YIELD RATE好看点.

ROSS和DUKE是中国申请人的保底学校,申请的中国人众多.从今年的情况看,DUKE的申请人要多于ROSS.申请的人多了,录的人就多了.往后几年,各个学校里的中国人还会越来越多.俺基本上觉得这是好事.

千万不要说，中国人多了,教学质量就差了这种话.

俺估计WHARTON今年至少招50个中国人.哈哈,这也挡不住W是好学校啊,这严重说明W比H和S都有眼光.其实比较起S的规模,招的中国人的比例也不算少了。想要班上只有1个中国人，估计得早申请10年,哈哈

cgcg

i second ddtt.  duke's known for its nice alum/adcom/students.  it didn't get the name for no reason.  as far as the students, adcom, alumni (from both China and the States) i interacted with, they were all friendly and helpful.  i personally wouldn't have given such a biased comment.

JeffBJ

以下是引用Huangzizeng在2007-3-13 2:30:00的发言：

楼上说的对啊,insead比哈佛都牛啊.

而且据说老师也很强,不是一个档次的.

兄弟，这个有点夸张啦吧，呵呵，哈佛从哪个方面来说，都是No.1啊。也许不适合某些人，但是无论从名声，还是实力，确实是超一流的。

george_hcl

Kinchan 同学，不过是要用事实说话咯

比较两个学校的找工作情况

1, duke (05-06), total student size 400

GS(4) MS(2). ML(3). LB(5), BA(11) JP(2) CITI(12)

UBS(0) DB(0) CS(1) BC(0) HSBC(1)

MCK(8), BCG(0) BAIN(6)

2 INSEAD (05-06), total student size 800

GS(0) MS(0). ML(6). LB(7), BA(0) JP(0) CITI(5)

UBS(6) DB(18) CS(1) BC(11) HSBC(5)

MCK(74), BCG(40) BAIN(30)

所以说，duke's consulting sucks, insead's finance, especially placement for american-based bank sucks

话说回来，duke's finace also sucks becuase big placement in bank of amercia and citibank may all the commerial bank jobs.

averu

insead的gs，ms，jpm都至少有3个人，cs有10个人。。career report看的不仔细啊，他家的career report只是列出了去向最多的雇佣者。其他雇用3人以上的只是都用bold表示了

以香港的buldge blacket banks来说，除了m7的mba以外，基本就是insead和lbs。。虽然美国的多一些

可能有一些孤陋，在香港几个银行都没有见过杜克的