[揽瓜阁精读] 305. 18th century music

Clara006

early music movement：
play as it was performed at that time
  aw+: value
  Aw-: profound & troubling

Only for instruments available
   but B can't play eg. High F （他想play但是play不了）
   按当时的条件弹frustrating B

Divorce from life
Audible VS Piano inaudible

Faster , last slower  VS today:
  applauded at the end of each VS end of entire work( extra brilliance)
  按原来的方式弹 irrational denial <-- concepts of musical changed

XX829412

看一下！               

XX829412

        • Early music：  Paly old music on obsolete instrument
        • Questions
                ○ Assume: only for the instrumet available
                        § But Beethoven:
                                □ Pianos : no F-sharp
                ○ Divorce music from the life
                        § Early music
                                □ + H & M's symphonies: conducted during their lifetime
                                □  - Despite: orchestral piano : inaudible
                        § Although
                                □ first 3 sections: faster
                                □ Last: slower
                        § Reason:
                                □ At that time: applause each movement
                                □ Now: applause the end of entire work

Dreambig13

Mark一下！               

FROM2024

305 18世纪的音乐
1.提出早期音乐活动的表演形式，提出这种方式有深远意义和困扰。
2.早期音乐都适应当时的乐器的，举了个贝多芬升f调作为例外。
3.早期音乐通常跟生活分割开来。海顿和莫扎特交响曲在他们的生活中被演奏催生了早期音乐录音。19世纪早期莫扎特和贝多芬交响曲的前三部分都比较快，快结束的时候比较慢，这解释了这跟现在结束时候才给予掌声是不同的。

Miya422

Main point：Disscuss and question the early music movement.

P1: Introduction of early music movement: play old music on obsolete instruments
           --- inestimate value to scholars;
           --- raise profound and troubling questions

P2:  Early music advocates assume play only on avaliable instruments
           --- refute by evidence of Beethoven: (imagine high & low notes, Piano can'y play F-Sharp)

P3: Early music advocates divoce music from the life which they are a part.
           --- refute evidence from Mozart and H
           --- 19th: first 3 sections played faster, the last slower----leave time for audiences applauded
           --- Difference with today as now applause the end of entire work
      
Author's Opinion( not support):  restore the original music --- irrational denial of the fact (our concepts of musical have changed).

darcyzhx

看一下

小熏小姐

Mark一下！               

echoooo3333

康康

阿凡有达

看一下！