[揽瓜阁逻辑小分队] day72

小连oooo

1、A： 种在narrow strip 的tree能够减少水资源的蒸发，所以remove这些tree并不一定会增加available water。
2、一个head不能兼顾多个company，加强了结论。
3、develop a new tollway并不意味着一定能够make money，toll fee的收取权可能不在private company，就算可以collect，不一定会有大量使用者

NWUZS

Mark一下！               

NWUZS

Day 72
1.        在河边种树
In the arid land along the Colorado River, use of the river's water supply is strictly controlled：farms along the river each have a limited allocation that they are allowed to use for irrigation.But the trees that grow in narrow strips along the river's banks also use its water.Clearly, therefore, if farmers were to remove those trees, more water would be available for crop irrigation.
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
A.The trees along the river's banks shelter it from the sun and wind, thereby greatly reducing the amount of water lost through evaporation.
B.Owners of farms along the river will probably not undertake the expense of cutting down trees along the banks unless they are granted a greater allocation of water in return.
C.Many of the tree species currently found along the river's banks are specifically adapted to growing in places where tree roots remain constantly wet.
D.The strip of land where trees grow along the river's banks would not be suitable for growing crops if the trees were removed.
E.The distribution of water allocations for irrigation is intended to prevent farms farther upstream from using water needed by farms farther downstream.、A

2.        辞职的主管
department head. a lot of department heads would retire while the number of qualified person for new head is only half of the posts, which results in the shortage of heads. Many departments of the company will have no head for the company，since...
部门总数没有减少

3.        没钱修路的政府
A government plans to develop new road, but doesn't have the money. So the government will let a private company to take on the task and develop a new tollway. Oppose: the government let the private company make too much money by collecting toll fees.
Q: What weaken the opponent's argument?
收费权掌握在政府手中

Marvnt

同意！               

Marvnt

1. A
P：水资源缺乏，而沿河的树木会消耗水
C：将树木砍掉则可节约水给种植玉米
  只要clear砍掉树木并不能够节约水份（树木本身具有贮存水分的作用）就可以选出正确答案
  因此我认为选A

2. 首先理解意思！
   部门主管即将退休，而新的合格人数为职位的一半，因此主管人数不够
   需要去补充逻辑链的漏洞
   即新主管不能兼任多个职位/老主管不再返聘

3. weaken：如果没能够修路，那么人们所花费的人力将远远大于poll/政府有额外对于私人公司的限制

petittomato

看一下！               

petittomato

1.        在河边种树
A
排除D：D说的只是the strip of land，一部份地方而不是全部的farm，题目中也没说crop只种在这个地方

2.        辞职的主管
a lot of department heads would retire while the number of qualified person for new head is only half of the posts, which results in the shortage of heads. Many departments of the company will have no head for the company，since...
即使全部的申请者都上岗，也不够post

3.        没钱修路的政府
A government plans to develop new road, but doesn't have the money. So the government will let a private company to take on the task and develop a new tollway. Oppose: the government let the private company make too much money by collecting toll fees.
Q: What weaken the opponent's argument?
收的钱都交给government
gov支付给company的钱是fixed的

F_Hillary

看一下！               

luchenfeng

看一下！               

luchenfeng

1.C ：把河边的树砍掉 灌溉农作物的水就会更多  
削弱 我的立场是砍掉树不可能使得灌溉的水更多 那就是砍掉树和减少源头水有关联 A
2.不招人 同时符合条件的领导了一半 结论是很多部门明年都会没有领导
解释 没有存在足够的单个领导可以领导几个部门的情况
3.削弱 就是私人公司收过路费也不会赚很多钱 可以说收费标准还是政府制定的 私人公司不过就是执行的傀儡罢了