分享各商学院 PhD Programs 就业出路及相关方面的信息，欢迎讨论！

Tripleg

福玻斯 发表于 2020-3-18 12:09
感谢楼主的收集总结以及这么长时间以来不停的回答大家的问题！真是收益匪浅！
我想问问楼主关于录取后选校 ...

Thank you very much for your trust and encouragement.

We would suggest that you give TAMU more serious consideration. UTD is a rapidly rising star, but TAMU is a more established and better-known brand, and so placements prospects are more assured. With respect to research in finance, both rank quite well and meet your needs.

UB and UIUC are very similar to TAMU.

Tripleg

tangjinyi 发表于 2020-3-18 17:29
楼主你好，请问 UTD 和UConn的strategy方向 phd怎么比较呢？同在TIER 3。
据我了解的 UTD 系大，每年招的人 ...

We are not familiar with this area of concentration, but UTD, with its rapid ascendance, would be a better choice. UCONN seems to have been going downhill in recent years.

CCdreamer

感谢楼主提供的信息！
可以请教一下，UC RIVERSIDE这种没有什么数据的新项目，可以从什么角度去考量？
如果没有数据是不是能直接默认基本没有去到好学校的例子直接划分到TIER5以后了？

福玻斯

Tripleg 发表于 2020-3-22 23:21
Thank you very much for your trust and encouragement.

We would suggest that you give TAMU more se ...

感谢大佬的建议！

Tripleg

CCdreamer 发表于 2020-3-23 14:53
感谢楼主提供的信息！
可以请教一下，UC RIVERSIDE这种没有什么数据的新项目，可以从什么角度去考量？
如果 ...

UC Riverside is unranked and not shown in our placement ranking primarily because it is an unusual and potentially concerning case. This program was established around ten years ago, but currently has only a handful of enrolled students and has provided no placement information.

Tripleg

熊二xx 发表于 2020-3-11 20:02
好的，感谢楼主 一直在等你的答复，buffalo的finance phd 的placement很混，没有按年份分 请问你有知道 ...

Hope you will make up your mind in a short while. The reason you are wavering between Buffalo and Kansas is that the two look similar at first sight in terms of overall research profile and recent placements (we are using the modifier "recent" because many Buffalo graduates had joined top schools, such as Michigan Ross, until some years back). As mentioned, if you do well enough in either Buffalo or Kansas, you will have a good chance of landing a research school. There is no doubt about that. Buffalo has a research emphasis on AP, but students also have the opportunity to do CF.

Despite the above seeming similarity, Buffalo is definitely stronger. As evidence, Buffalo has been consisstently on the list of ASU Ranking and has a very large number of publications in top finance journals, including JFE, whereas Kansas has never appeared in ASU Ranking and virtually has none in top journals. Kansas has at least five faculty who are recent PhDs; do not expect them to help you in research or be involved in your dissertation.  

By the way, both Buffalo and Kansas are very small programs. Each has below ten enrolled students, and Kansas may have even fewer. Kansas admits no more than one or two students (or even none occasionally) a year based on faculty research strengths and financial resources available. They insist upon doing so because they want to ensure that all students are well supprted and successful. That's why they are doing well and are praised for being a rising star of sorts.

熊二xx

Tripleg 发表于 7小时前
By the way, both Buffalo and Kansas are very small...

您的回答让我受益匪浅，还有一个问题是，buffalo的funding是不是左右2w每年（听说的）？相比之下KU有2.9w

donnotknow

熊二xx 发表于 2020-3-27 09:10
您的回答让我受益匪浅，还有一个问题是，buffalo的funding是不是左右2w每年（听说的）？相比之下KU有2.9 ...

Funding真不是PhD考虑的主要问题，举个例子Chicago不给你钱，KU给你一年五万，你会去哪里读PhD?

熊二xx

donnotknow 发表于 12分钟前
Funding真不是PhD考虑的主要问题，举个例子Chicago不给你钱，KU给你一年五万，你会去哪...

当然了，你的这个问题是送分题 我是因为这两个学校没那么显著的差距，所以就略微考虑了一会funding

古天乐

熊二xx 发表于 2020-3-27 12:47
当然了，你的这个问题是送分题 我是因为这两个学校没那么显著的差距，所以就略微考虑了一会funding ...

读博嘛，在哪读都是吃低保，没有本质区别。心里喜欢哪个就选哪个。一个要呆五年而且是五年艰苦生活的地方。把钱做为主要考虑因素，以后遇到不顺会难免打自己脸“当初真不该图那几千块来着”。我觉得这两个都极好。如何是我，我会回想一路跟他们的沟通来往，选让我最舒服的哪个。