TTGWD25-3 帮帮忙！！！

tidusyuna

应该是C.

Mel的论述中,结论明显是

The legislature’s move to raise the salary has

done nothing to improve the situation

Pat的response:No, the raise in salary really does improve the situation.也正是P的conclusion.后面是premise.

所以c项attempts to argue that a certain change will have a positive effect,正是它论点所在,而merely by pointing to the absence of negative effects是指出由premise到conlusion的推理错误.

A项重心明显是关于premise的,而response 应该是对应于conclusion的.

 

 

The legislature’s move to raise the salary has

done nothing to improve the situation

Pat的response:No, the raise in salary really does improve the situation.也正是P的conclusion.后面是premise.

所以c项attempts to argue that a certain change will have a positive effect,正是它论点所在,而merely by pointing to the absence of negative effects是指出由premise到conlusion的推理错误.

A项重心明显是关于premise的,而response 应该是对应于conclusion的.

 

 

wsdoll

up...

riverquiet

I]:----(

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-10-7 4:19:02编辑过]

sch

C不对,通过指出没有坏处,来证明有好处.哪里对哪里


其实主要错误是,正是因为ban了,所以才没有人教书讲座开班讲课,用了结果当作原因.

找出描述这种错误的选项

weideng

可以用AWA的思路,如果这道是AA题,大家一定能想到all things are equal的错误吧

lichabrend

up

yzhao26

up

MarilynR

本来我也选的C，现在想通了选A。

C说通过说明没有负面影响而证明该变化有正面影响à文章没有说
  没有负面影响
  这一点。

A中的Potential member 指的是现在不是judge，但有可能因为工资待遇调高而成为judge的人。（这些人很有可能在大学教书）

Pat只是说明了现在的judge里很少人教书，但这并不意味着potential member不会想要教书。搞不好人家教习惯了会很想keep it as a part time job.

Open to discussion.

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-6-12 11:43:49编辑过]

bigzigzag

"the ban will have little or no negative effect."  =    by pointing to the absence of negative effects

In pat's argument , " Since very few judges teach or give lectures, the ban will have little or no negative effect. " is the cause

"No, the raise in salary really does improve the situation." is the result.

that is not correct.

夜凉如水

以下是引用MarilynR在2008-6-12 11:42:00的发言：

本来我也选的C，现在想通了选A。

C说通过说明没有负面影响而证明该变化有正面影响à文章没有说
  没有负面影响
  这一点。

A中的Potential member 指的是现在不是judge，但有可能因为工资待遇调高而成为judge的人。（这些人很有可能在大学教书）

Pat只是说明了现在的judge里很少人教书，但这并不意味着potential member不会想要教书。搞不好人家教习惯了会很想keep it as a part time job.

Open to discussion.

嗯想通了 谢谢