MIT还是Tuck?

dreamland

排名不是最重要，甚至不是重要的。

你觉得找工作和学校名望，校友网络相关，但是更重要的是你自己，如何利用学校品牌，校友关系，你会积极主动有效的networking吗？你知道如何推销自己吗？公司同时在10所商学院招人，看得不是你学到多少知识，还是你这个人是否出类拔萃。做过了商学院的面试，在校学生做过了咨询公司的case study，你一定知道底气和表现的关系，当你明白who you are, what you can bring, what you cannot, and where you want to be，你一定可以信心十足地表现你的commitment和potential.但是你怎样才能实现对自己的了解呢？

我们大概一辈子都在了解自己。90%进入商学院的人都想在一个转折的阶段认识自己。

(sorry, typing in Chinese is so slow.....)

Think back of our life line, there is some 'people' playing a critical role at each key decision you made.

People is the motivation of your development and change.

Interaction with people keeps us grow.

That is where Tuck fits in:

• A group study set up make sure you have five other bodies watching you evolve each term, you meet them every day, there is no where you could hide or escape. Feedback is given whenever you require them.


• Close-knit community means you can always walk into a professor, director's door, seeking mentorship, talking concerns. Whenever you need attention.


• Outdoor-oriented environment teach you how important sports/nature is for a balanced life, and a richer experience.


• Integrated General Management curriculum prepare you for a challenging job right after graduation. You'll know how much you improved personally and professionaly during the summer internship.

Depending upon your personality/career goals, that is ALL making the decision. Good luck!

(If you need to talk a Tuckie from MIT or chose Tuck over MIT before, let me know. Not to convince you, but to offer more perspective before you made a decision. I was there, I know how hard it could be.)

wolftian

首先谢谢各位的热心回复和帮助!

我今天和我们公司的人事总监及其它一些高层管理人员聊过：他们认为从我现在所在公司来看，公司不在乎我是上tuck还是MIT，甚至HBS,因为这些商学院在公司看来都非常好，都非常优秀，而且我在公司的经历已经证明我非常出色!如果公司真的资助的话，不会因为MIT或者HBS就多给点，也不会因为上的是duke或者tuck就少给点!

从我本人来说：我个人很喜欢上tuck,因为teamwork非常的强，general management很突出，但是考虑到我毕业之后，不打算在美国工作，只想回国发展!

从国内名气的角度来说，我想会选择MIT!还有我在大学的时候学的技术专业，只是工作后做了销售和市场，MIT会给我在把握相关技术发展潮流及如何正确确立技术发展战略等相关方面会有很大的帮助吧!

再次谢谢各位的帮助!

jessicaf

MIT and Tuck actually are not on the same level. Maybe Tuck nowadays ranks higher, but have you analyzed why? Teamwork actually doesn't mean much for your future career and job hunting after MBA study, which is the most important for you who will pay so much money and precious time.

You asked MIT or Tuck. This question only shows that you don't understand the true market value of these B-schools.

wolftian

以下是引用jessicaf在2006-2-1 14:33:00的发言：

MIT and Tuck actually are not on the same level. Maybe Tuck nowadays ranks higher, but have you analyzed why? 看到这，我想问您，不知您是否了解why?可否讲给我听听？

Teamwork actually doesn't mean much for your future career and job hunting after MBA study, which is the most important for you who will pay so much money and precious time. 你是如何理解teamwork？能否指点指点？我相信您的能力再强，如何与team中的成员合作还是非常非常重要的!

You asked MIT or Tuck. This question only shows that you don't understand the true market value of these B-schools.

从您的话来看，您是比较理解the true market value of these B-schools. !愿闻其详!

iampig123

不好说. 就象有些中国学生会觉的 耶鲁 MBA 比 U PENN 的好.

"--  作者：jessicaf
MIT and Tuck actually are not on the same level. Maybe Tuck nowadays ranks higher, but have you analyzed why? Teamwork actually doesn't mean much for your future career and job hunting after MBA study, which is the most important for you who will pay so much money and precious time.

You asked MIT or Tuck. This question only shows that you don't understand the true market value of these B-school"

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-2-1 15:42:36编辑过]

BJ2003

Tuck and Harvard 才是一个林黛玉，一个薛宝钗。Tuck一年才收240-260人，是最小的MBA Program, Harvard一年收900+,属最大的之列。

Tuck student body is generally known for being "supportive" while Harvard is generally known from being "competitive"

These two facts should already told some difference

Downside at Tuck: if you are going back to China, you might need to explain where you graduate from sometimes, but definitely not to any Consulting or I-banking firms.

marina_sun

Tuck 这里很少有industry的公司来，所以Tuck和industry的connection非常弱。而且受规模和位置的限制都比较严重。不过要是你有孩子带到Tuck生活到是不错的。除此之外就没有什么好比较的了。

wenzhang

if you would like to return, How many people in China know Tuck?

messiah

如果要回国.建议MIT

小嘴金鱼

I vote for MIT for sure