gwd17-34急求问

junguo21c

Q34:

During the month of May, crabs arrive on Delaware’s beaches to lay eggs.  Certain shorebirds depend on these eggs for food during their annual spring migration to their northern breeding grounds.  Delaware’s crab population has declined recently.  This decline, however, poses no serious threat to the migrating shorebird populations:  by remaining longer in Delaware, the birds will be able to eat enough crab eggs to allow them to complete their migration.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?

No other food available to the birds on Delaware’s beaches is as nutritious and accessible as are crab eggs.

The decline in the number of crabs on Delaware’s beaches is due to the harvesting of crabs by humans.

There are more crabs on Delaware’s beaches than in any other area that the migrating birds pass through.

The crabs do not conceal their eggs.

The earlier in the season the shorebirds complete their migration, the more likely they are to breed successfully.

我是在DE徘徊，答案是E，我觉得D是不是也有些道理。

Crab没有把Egg藏起来，该吃的已经吃完了，Shorebird再等下去也不会有什么作用，所以weaken.

yangxiaogang

楼主还没有习惯gmat的思维方式，不可加进任何自己的推论。答案是E

jason00

Q34:

During the month of May, crabs arrive on Delaware’s beaches to lay eggs.  Certain shorebirds depend on these eggs for food during their annual spring migration to their northern breeding grounds.  Delaware’s crab population has declined recently.  This decline, however, poses no serious threat to the migrating shorebird populations:  by remaining longer in Delaware, the birds will be able to eat enough crab eggs to allow them to complete their migration.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?

1. No other food available to the birds on Delaware’s beaches is as nutritious and accessible as are crab eggs. 无关， 即使没有， 不能削弱靠延长时间来得到足够鸟蛋的可能性


2. The decline in the number of crabs on Delaware’s beaches is due to the harvesting of crabs by humans. 无关


3. There are more crabs on Delaware’s beaches than in any other area that the migrating birds pass through. 增强


4. The crabs do not conceal their eggs. 无关


5. The earlier in the season the shorebirds complete their migration, the more likely they are to breed successfully.

题干的推导关系为：蟹蛋量下降，但没有影响靠蛋哺育的鸟的数量，原因是鸟可以通过延长找蛋的时间来吃到足够多的蛋。E说越早来，哺育越成功。即晚来的可能失败，削弱题干推导关系。 削弱原推导所赖的依据

llfllfllf

谢谢jason00, 你 解释题目很清楚啊,

第二个Lawyer!

GawainERIC

以下是引用jason00在2006-3-19 13:02:00的发言：

Q34:

During the month of May, crabs arrive on Delaware’s beaches to lay eggs.  Certain shorebirds depend on these eggs for food during their annual spring migration to their northern breeding grounds.  Delaware’s crab population has declined recently.  This decline, however, poses no serious threat to the migrating shorebird populations:  by remaining longer in Delaware, the birds will be able to eat enough crab eggs to allow them to complete their migration.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?

1. No other food available to the birds on Delaware’s beaches is as nutritious and accessible as are crab eggs.
                       无关，
                       即使没有，
                       不能削弱靠延长时间来得到足够鸟蛋的可能性

2. The decline in the number of crabs on Delaware’s beaches is due to the harvesting of crabs by humans. 无关
3. There are more crabs on Delaware’s beaches than in any other area that the migrating birds pass through.
                       增强
4. The crabs do not conceal their eggs. 无关
                   
5. The earlier in the season the shorebirds complete their migration, the more likely they are to breed successfully.

题干的推导关系为：蟹蛋量下降，但没有影响靠蛋哺育的鸟的数量，原因是鸟可以通过延长找蛋的时间来吃到足够多的蛋。E说越早来，哺育越成功。即晚来的可能失败，削弱题干推导关系。
            削弱原推导所赖的依据

我的理解如下：

the birds will be able to eat enough crab eggs to allow them to complete their migration.

这是文章的结论，结论只提到了migration是否成功，根本没有提到breed是否成功．

因此我认为只要migration是否成功就可以了，而breed是否成功就变成了无关．所以我坚决的把Ｅ排除了．

阿土莎莎

up

rmbaos

以下是引用GawainERIC在2007-8-17 22:23:00的发言：

我的理解如下：

the birds will be able to eat enough crab eggs to allow them to complete their migration.

这是文章的结论，结论只提到了migration是否成功，根本没有提到breed是否成功．

因此我认为只要migration是否成功就可以了，而breed是否成功就变成了无关．所以我坚决的把Ｅ排除了．

agree, unless the "migration" is defined to include the breed part.

yzhao26

up

yzhao26

thanks

I vote for E

xinyp

那么B为什么错呢？B说crab都被抓走了，鸟再等也不会有更多的蛋可吃了，不是削弱吗？