GWD-28-7<---ethyl更改标题（GWD 28-7 好像还没有标准答案，大家选啥？）

v22

偶怎么觉得是E呢？

v22

现在想想还是选C了。R猴子都已经最aggressive了，他们在crowded conditions下，都表现得attacks did not become any more frequent，更何况其他猴子呢？是不是

E就不是那码事，咱就选了个E？？

sherryly

选A， A指出即使在不拥挤的环境下，猴子也有这种反应，因此说明这种反应和拥挤无关。

mojomojo

C

ayang1017

答案c，我记得我做过，在这里ac其实都是支持

但是其实在逻辑题里也存在比较的概念，也就是谁支持的程度更大，仔细分析ac就会发现

是c的程度更大

liu977

这题还是想再提出来讨论一下，怎么也想不通为什么选C不选A，我想问题出在两个地方的理解：

1。原题结论是：因此，不是所有种类的猴子都和老鼠一样容易受到拥挤的刺激。这个不存在所谓的绝对化问题，退一步说，即使其它猴子都受刺激，根据文章可知Rhesus猴是不受刺激的，因此这个结论还是成立的。这个结论其实是很自然推出来的，就是说R猴不受刺激，所以推出不是所有猴子都受刺激。这个结论如果改写成：所有猴子都不受刺激，那才存在样本代表问题。

2。对于选项的理解：a wider range到底是指范围广还是程度广不好说，如果是范围广的话，则该选项无关，在此保持沉默

A的正确性在于，文章很明确的说了crowding increase 了rat的刺激，又说虽然R猴Increase in "coping"，但还是说明R猴不受刺激，那自然要强调一下coping的增加不代表crowding的刺激作用才好

Open to discuss...

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-10-10 18:23:54编辑过]

chenfruit

Crowded ---> Rats attack

Crowded----> R.monkey   no    attack

結論: (為何用單一品種R猴子居然可推出全部猴子的習性!)

In a crowded space,

all monkey are  not likely to act as Rats do  

綜上所述,

R猴,之所以可代表全部猴子乃因為它接受crowded的程度最低      

它都可以成立了,全部猴子當然也可以成立! 舉重以明輕!

答案是C

shashaxz

for any monkeys，这个是个tricky。根本不是样本的问题，题目的意思是，对任何一种猴子来说，crowd都会引起打斗，是不太可能的。any monkey不等于all the monkey

那么r猴肯定是一种猴子，那么题目可以改写成，对于r猴来说，因crowd会引起打斗，是不可能的。

那么答案就应该是E了！

redyoyo

agree with E

modest

A: All the observed forms of coping behavior can be found among rhesus monkeys living in uncrowded conditions.

"uncrowded" or "crowed " lead to the same consequense. weaken

B: In the studies of rats, nondominant individuals were found to increasingly avoid dominant individuals when the animals were in crowded conditions.

has no business with monkey

C: Rhesus monkeys respond with aggression to a wider range of stimuli than any other monkeys do.

opposite  to the conclusion"Therefore it is not likely that, for any species of monkey, crowding increases aggression as significantly as was seen in rats."

D: Some individual monkeys in the experiment were involved in significantly more attacks than the other monkeys were.

opposite  to the conclusion

E: Some of the coping behavior displayed by rhesus monkeys is similar to behavior rhesus monkeys use to bring to an end an attack that has begun

strengthen. so i choose e.