求问PREP 71按helr方法分类为什么是因果

猫小雯雯

71.In order to improve the long-term savings rate of its citizens, Levaska’s government has decided to introduce special savings accounts.  Citizens can save up to $3,000 a year in special accounts without having to pay tax on the interest, unless they withdraw money from the account before they reach the age of sixty-five.  If they do withdraw any money before that age, they have to pay tax on the accumulated interest and a penalty.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously threatens the success of the government’s plan?

A. The banks and financial institutions where the special accounts will be held lobbied hard for their introduction.

B. Nearly all workers in Levaska can already save money in tax-free accounts through their workplace.

C. For the past ten years, Levaskans have been depositing an ever smaller percentage of their income in long-term savings.

D. Many Levaskans continue to work beyond the age of sixty-five.

E. In certain circumstances, such as a serious illness, the government plans to waive the penalty on early withdrawals from the special accounts.         B

这道题目，逻辑笔记里面helr是将它分类为因果模式，我想请问为什么不是方案推理呢？最后一句我觉得是对这个方案内容的解释，说如果在65岁之前取钱就需要支付利息和惩罚。选B的CQ方向是方案的可行性。请大家指点一下~~谢谢啦~

zingshaw

很多人问这个归类的问题。我没看过herl的逻辑方法和归类，我觉得理解推理过程中的gap是最重要的。哪个选项是合理的？为什么比其他合理？ 理解了就行，没必要纠结归为哪一类。

猫小雯雯

zingshaw 发表于 2014-11-16 23:17
很多人问这个归类的问题。我没看过herl的逻辑方法和归类，我觉得理解推理过程中的gap是最重要的。哪个选项 ...

是这样的，herl的方法是从出题的角度分的类，如果推理模式正确的话，基本上是不会错的，每一类推理模式都有自己固定的CQ方向，慢慢的消化就会变成自己的东西~~推荐你看一下

zingshaw

恩，反正你理解就行。。我都考过了。就不看了。。