大全-II-14 新问题！！！论坛上没有相关问题！！！求帮助！！！

几米的世界9

大全-Ⅱ-14.

Some analysts maintain that an embargo by country Litora on the export of a strategic metal to country Zenda, if imposed, would drive up the price of the metal in Zenda at least tenfold. They note that few other countries export the metal and that, with an embargo, Zenda might have to depend on as-yet-unexploited domestic sources of the metal.
Which of the following, if true, constitutes the most serious objection to the analysis above?
(A) Litora’s economy depends heavily on foreign currency earned by the export of the strategic metal to other countries.
(B) There are foreign-policy steps that Zenda could take to appease Litora and avoid being subjected to an embargo on the metal.
(C) Geologists believe that additional deposits of the metal could possibly be found within the territory of Litora.
(D) Only a small proportion of Zenda’s import expenditures is devoted to the import of the metal from Litora.
(E) In case of an embargo, Zenda could buy the metal indirectly from Litora on the world market at a less than one-third increase in cost.

答案是E，我也觉得这个答案是最佳的，但是我怀疑E方法的可行性：
题干中说了' few other countries export the metal (没有其他国家出口metal)，那么L从国际市场上买的metal算不算是一种进口，卖家算不算出口呢？

谢谢谢谢！！！

几米的世界9

up！！！！！

几米的世界9

有没有同学解释一下呢，我觉得这题有点自相矛盾，world market不是应该建立在有至少两个国家出口的基础上嘛？给点提示吧还是我想太多了

几米的世界9

up。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。

duanfly123

我怎么觉得答案应该是b呢？e的逻辑有问题，像题主所说，而b指出embargo有可能根本不会发生，难道不是最大的质疑吗？

几米的世界9

duanfly123 发表于 2014-9-7 11:14
我怎么觉得答案应该是b呢？e的逻辑有问题，像题主所说，而b指出embargo有可能根本不会发生，难道不是最大的 ...

我认为B的问题在于其否定了结论的前提条件，题目中结论就是with an embargo, Zenda might xxx，在削弱题型中否认前提是错误的：）