求教gwd一道题，请大家帮我，谢谢

moymoe

Mel:  The official salary for judges has always been too low to attract the best candidates to the job. The legislature's move to raise the salary has done nothing to improve the situation, because it was coupled with a ban on receiving money for lectures and teaching engagements.
Pat:  No, the raise in salary really does improve the situation. Since very few judges teach or give lectures, the ban will have little or no negative effect.
Pat's response to Mel is inadequate in that it

A    attempts to assess how a certain change will affect potential members of a group by providing evidence about its effect on the current members.
B    mistakenly takes the cause of a certain change to be an effect of that change
Cattempts to argue that a certain change will have a positive effect merely by pointing to the absence of negative effects
D   simply denies Mel's claim without putting forward any evidence in support of that denial
E   assumes that changes that benefit the most able members of a group necessarily benefit all members of that group.
为什么选a不选e呢？希望nn们帮我

bergkamp91

问题是P这个人的话里面，哪里有提到most被benifit了呢，我觉得P这人的话的重点应该是BAN这个东西啊，应该针对P通过Ban了很少的人就得出Ban的总体效果不行来批判吧，你看a不是更好么，current members是被ban的很少的那部分人，potential members是全体的judges，个人拙见，楼主在斟酌斟酌~

moymoe

bergkamp91 发表于 2013-8-18 10:29
问题是P这个人的话里面，哪里有提到most被benifit了呢，我觉得P这人的话的重点应该是BAN这个东西啊，应该针 ...

确实是affect比benifit用的更好一些。以后逻辑题也要注意咬文嚼字了啊
谢谢你