天山-7-17

evonneangela

up  D!!

justintime

the second provides grounds for holding that the practice cannot achieve its objective.

the cannot is wrong;:he arguer have not mention whether this practice can achieve goal or not,but just refered to the other better choices without side-effect.

steveyangxt

以下是引用小I爱漂漂在2005-2-7 16:12:00的发言：

我的理解是， 因为h公司的objective是“wants its managers to have international experience”，只是由于培训以后那些经理要跳槽，但是它确实是achieve the objective的，也就是'"wants its managers to have international experience“了的。

支持

nijiz

pick D. over

easy4meeeeee

"both this function and the goal of providing international experience could be achieved in other ways"
means the company has already achieved its objectiv

C- cannot achieve its objective ,   is totally wrong

MarilynR

C和D比较的话，后半句D更好。

体会一下，both this function and the goal of providing international experience could be achieved in other ways-->更多的与没有必要 相联系，而不是在谈该措施不能打成其目的。

我做的时候在A和E间徘徊，最终选了A。

请哪位NN帮我分析一下A为什么不对？

xiaoda

up

cyyp

看了大家的讨论，C中的“cannot achieve its objective”确实有点问题。因为公司的objective就是要manager增加international experience，而这个objective也确实能够达到。

但是D中的“is not needed”我觉得也有问题。请看它的结论：Therefore, if the attrition problem cannot be successfully addressed, Hanchnut should discontinue the sponsorship program.

这里的discontinue是有前提的，就是如果attrition问题不能解决才考虑中止。所以说光看“both this function and the goal of providing international experience could be achieved in other way”是不能得出中止这项计划的结论的。

恶心的题目，希望考试的时候不要让我碰到！阿门！

lychee1842

我现在觉得不选C是因为 这个practice是可以达到它的objective的

公司的Objective就是想要员工有一点International experience 那么送员工出国肯定是行的呀

所以C错

melodymelod

"both this function and the goal of providing international experience could be achieved in other ways"

means it's possible to achieve its objective otherwise.

So C is incorrect.

D is better.