[求助]天山4-12

Maggiewjy

agree with upstair

IceOnMe

今天刚做到这题,有些和前面不一样的认识,拿出来再讨论一下

错选了A,但现在觉得是E更好

E的结构是: farmer keep the cows cool, provided with, and milked ...

意思是famer保证牛们凉爽,有高热量的食物,并且挤奶时间规则,....

过去分词 provided, milked 和cool一样是一个形容词的成分

所以应该是三个形容词(短语)的并列

A:

1) 如果想构成并列,但显然无论怎么看它都不怎么并列,

要么是takes care to.. provides..., and milks...

或者to keep ..., to provide..., and to milk

2) 如果说后面的现在分词表伴随的话更加awkward. 因此A不对

不知最近有没有人在看这题

顺便B4一下ETS, 太狡诈

xinfaxian

以下是引用anyname在2005-3-20 11:10:00的发言：

支持E。这里过去分词应该没有歧义，至少不比现在分词更歧义（cows provide and milk?）。而且E比A简洁，A里providing them..., milking them...，them重复太多次。

For the farmer who takes care to keep them cool, provided with high-energy feed, and milked regularly, Holstein cows will produce an average of 2,275 gallons of
milk each per year.

等于

Provided with high-energy feed, and milked regularly, Holstein cows will produce an average of 2,275 gallons of milk each per year for the farmer who takes care to keep them cool.

顶一个，支持e. anyname gg 分析得很精彩哦！

diehard

支持一下A

For the farmer who takes care to keep them cool, providing them with high-energy feed, and milking them regularly,可以看出A选项和前面结合的不错

jerrold0023

一个问题：

分词表示伴随状态，是否只用在修饰主句？修饰从句是否可行？

我想AE的区别应该在这里。

哪位N能解答一下。

华籍美人

同意anyname的说法，选E，providing分词才是个夹心饼干呢！them太罗嗦了

过去分词会有这种情况么？一般不会吧。

Xandria

简洁是要在没有歧义的前提下面才可以, 过去分词夹心修饰肯定不好

jnlvo

这题如果E是Holstein cows , 则E is best.

实际cool，provided with high-energy feed, and milked regularly平行。

keepforward

iceonme有理，支持！

yukon

这道题没白错，不然就看不到大家的精彩讨论了！只是还有一点不明白，E末了为什么用将来时啊？