Prep12 逻辑第10题答案貌似错了呀 求确认

cuteamethyst

Prep2012-Pack1-CR-010 VCR004721 Easy
Paper&Print is a chain of British stores selling magazines, books, and stationery products. In Britain, magazines’ retail prices are set by publishers, and the retailer’s share of a magazine's retail price 25 percent. Since Paper&Print’s margin on books and stationery products is much higher, the chain's management plans to devote more of its stores’ shelf space to books and stationery products and reduce the number of magazine titles that its stores carry.
Which of the following, if true, most strongly argues that the plan, if put into effect, will increase Paper&Print’s profits?
A. Recently magazine publishers, seeking to increase share in competitive sectors of the market, have been competitively cutting the retail prices of some of the largest circulation magazines.
B. In market research surveys, few consumers identify Paper&Print as a book or stationery store but many recognize and value the broad range of magazines it carries.
C. The publisher’s share of a magazine's price is 50 percent, and the publisher also retains all of the magazine's advertising revenue.
D. Consumers who subscribe to a magazine generally pay less per issue than they would if they bought the magazine through a retail outlet such as Paper&Print.
E. Some of Paper&Print’s locations are in small towns and represent the only retail outlet for books within the community.

Reasoning
What would make it least likely that devoting more of the business to books and stationery, and less to magazines, would increase profits? The reasoning behind the plan is that Paper&Print has a greater profit margin on books and stationery than it can legally attain on magazines, and that carrying more items with higher profit margins and fewer with lower profit margins will increase overall profits. A weakness in this reasoning is that profits depend on actually selling items, not merely on carrying them. If magazines sell far more briskly than other merchandise, shelf space devoted to magazines may generate higher profits, despite the magazines’ lower profit margins. If this were the situation, the plan might backfire and fail to increase profits.
A. Lower retail prices on magazines could lower Paper&Print's profits per magazine sold and hence make the plan to devote more shelf space to merchandise other than magazines more likely to increase overall profits.
B. Correct. If far more customers shop at Paper&Print for its broad range of magazines than for its books and stationery, then cutting the shelf space devoted to magazines may disappoint the customers, reducing overall sales and profits.
C. Paper&Print‘s magazine profits come from the 25 percent of the magazines’ retail price that goes to the retailer, no matter who gets the rest.
D. This would tend to reduce Paper&Print's magazine sales and hence make the plan to devote more shelf space to merchandise other than magazines more likely to increase overall profits.
E. This would tend to increase Paper&Print’s book sales at some stores and hence make the plan to devote more shelf space to books rather than magazines more to increase overall profits.
The correct answer is B.

按照官方解释 增加profit的选项应该是D。大家来确认一下这不是我的幻觉~~~~~

zhouchenqi2013

顶一个~是不是题目问错了？

francoisyang

Which of the following, if true, most strongly argues that the plan, if put into effect, will increase Paper&Print’s profits?
问的是那个选项可以推翻增加利润

EnglandManu

考了下古，这道题应该是题目少打了个not，真汗。。。相关地址见：http://forum.chasedream.com/thread-131698-1-1.html
argue是个中性词汇，表示的是争论，并没有反对的意思，如argue for sth是支持sth，而argue against则是反对。

夏日之浅浅

是的。少了个not  http://forum.chasedream.com/thread-131698-1-1.html

moontroy

同意 的确是题目出错了 。。。正确的应该是argue against

藍色鑽石王

幸好，還想說我怎麼Easy還會做錯