doubt题求大牛~

shellin

The recently announced dissolution of the Freedom Party, a major national political party, will not benefit the one other major national political party, the Liberty Party. It will, however, help third parties, including the Workers Party, who will now take more votes away from the Liberty Party in the upcoming national presidential race than would have been taken by the Freedom Party, had it not been dissolved.

　　Which of the following, if true, would cast the most serious doubt on the claim made in the last sentence above?

A.Name recognition is a better predictor of a political party's success than how well its positions match with public opinion.

B.Most voters had considered the Freedom Party and the Liberty Party to have very similar positions on most key issues.
C.The Workers Party only runs political candidates in local elections, including those for city council members, assemblymen, and mayors.
D.Polls indicate that most voters believe that candidates for third parties are more honest and trustworthy than are candidates for major national parties.
E.The dissolution of a major political party inevitably causes many voters to change their longstanding voting habits and vote for parties they have never voted for in the past.正确答案C

本题华丽的选了E 翻译最后一句我理解是第三党在接下来的选举中拿到本应该属于FP(解散了)的LP的票
E选项 解散一个主要的政党让许多选民选择他们从来没有选过的党 我觉得削弱了= = 求解惑

FFD2012

我觉得答案应该是B吧  
如果不是那我也同求了

题目说 FP解散  TP受益而不是LP， （受益方法: FP的解散帮助TP从LP那里拿到更多本来会被FP拿走的票）
因此 如果LP和FP在政见上很多一致  那LP就会受益  而不是TP  



E的话:  个人认为  把TP和LP摆在同一个位置上了 （NEVER VOTED BEFORE）

同求解惑！！！

guotonghao123

最后一句我是这么理解的，第三党会比Freedom Party(如果没有解散的话）从Liberty Party的支持者中争取到更多的支持自己的选民。即如果有20人支持LP，第三党可以从那里拉到10名选民，FP可以拉到9或者更少的选民。

C项说WP只是在Local election中选举，所以FP这样的national对于它不会有太大的促进作用，从而否定了原文的结论。

shellin

再顶 为什么E选项不对?

guotonghao123

我是这么理解的，E项的话，说人们会支持他们以前没有支持过的党，这样的话，他们会支持另外两个党派中的一个，但是不清楚支持哪个的会多一些，所以E项不能削弱也不能支持

shellin

好像明白点了 谢啦~!!!

Estaban

C选项正确可以理解，问下B为什么不能削弱呢？

mashengyi

不选B的原因可以理解为C选项削弱的效果比B强吧