[求助]GWD-10-16

MayFair

I agree that D is better because the agreement(Should be 'appears') of E is not correct.

But I think the meaning of 'from' is not used as 'found sth from sth'.It should be "the bones are from the dinosaur. 

findjuhl

我支持选E，虽然E看上去罗嗦，但说明了意思，在难题里面意思正确大于结构正确

D的问题在，from会有歧义，到底修饰found还是bones呢？

E的问题是避免了歧义，表明from是修饰bones

giraffevoice

以下是引用litperi在2006-7-14 17:09:00的发言：

原句是“Digging at an oasis in the Egyptian desert, paleontologists have found huge fossil bones of what they say appears to have been the second most massive dinosaur that ever lived.”(http://www.hws.edu/alumni/alumnews/showwebclip.asp?webclipid=329)

这句可以理解为paleontologists have found *** of the second most massive dinosaur from desert

of 指出化石的来源 from说的是化石的出土位子 我觉得D别扭的地方在于

paleontologists have found huge fossil bones from what appears to be

from 应该改成of 不然from后面应该接一个地理位子

但是E

paleontologists have found huge fossil bones, which are from what appear to be

用which 避开了这个问题 说他们找到了石头 石头应该是从恐龙那里来的

如果大家觉得不对 请积极打击我

我也是根据句子的意思选E的。

如果选D，“考古学家从第二大恐龙里找到化石”，要知道“第二大恐龙”肯定也是化石呀，引申下去，原文就变成“考古学家从化石里找到化石”，简直是一句废话。

如果选E，“考古学家发现了化石，化石看来是从第二大恐龙里来的”，表达明确。

但是E中appear单复数确有问题，迷惑中。。。

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-10-7 22:36:19编辑过]

latuan1982

究竟选什么呢？恳请NN解答。。。。
感觉E 还挺有道理的，但是appear后面少了一个 s..........

yangjh1111

what可能是指代the Egyptian desert， the second most massive dinosaur生活的地方。

jimson1980

到底选D还是E阿 

qincong83

以下是引用MayFair在2006-7-30 13:04:00的发言：

I agree that D is better because the agreement(Should be 'appears') of E is not correct.

But I think the meaning of 'from' is not used as 'found sth from sth'.It should be "the bones are from the dinosaur. 

楼上请看解释，D

TTK

真是费解

ligaoping

这道题选D，大家可以查喳what的用法，忘记是白勇还是刘政民语法里说过what后面的谓语动词的单复数形式取决于后面的宾语，这道题the second most massive dinosaur是单数，故只能用appears.

阿土莎莎

那怎么答案是E啊。。

郁闷