gwd12-31,32新疑问？

MaccMichAA

居然看了moomoo前辈的帖子 仰视

加拿大帅哥

我觉得，可以从reach在这里的用法，来判定是A or E.

reach 这里应该是名词: "延伸”

既然是名词，根据用法和句子的意思应该是套用reach of 而不是reach for.

reach for 通常是reach 作动词的时候的搭配。

zaq12wsx

E选项的确是有逻辑问题，难道此题无解？

zaq12wsx

个人认为，E如果改成***, since gold-bearing riverbeds thrust to the surface by erosion, prehistoric movement, and volcanic activity put gold literally within reach of anybody with a pan or shovel. 逻辑上就清楚了；

chamcham

I agree A. Here is my thought about E:

If E is correct, lets try to only examine the subject, verb and object of the main clause:

.. letters ..., ... , outnumber her letters to anyone else.

I think it is apparently illogical if saying "letters outnumber letters to other letters". So E is wrong.

A is good, since the gerund "outnumbering" refers to the whole event described in the previous sentence. And that event makes her letters more than to anyone else. At least logically make sense to me.

Open to discuss.

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-6-11 7:47:03编辑过]

chamcham

I agree A. Here is my thought about E:

If E is correct, lets try to only examine the subject, verb and object of the main clause:

.. letters ..., ... , outnumber her letters to anyone else.

I think it is apparently illogical if saying "letters outnumber letters to other letters". So E is wrong.

A is good, since the gerund "outnumbering" refers to the whole event described in the previous sentence. And that event makes her letters more than to anyone else. At least logically make sense to me.

Open to discuss.

jiangyz

仔细考虑，我认为31题的答案选择E而不是A，分词结构放在句尾，只有两种成分：伴随状语或修饰语，做修饰语只能修饰紧跟的名词，显然，outnumbering不能作为修饰语，只能做伴随状语。

那么，你认为were written能够影响outnumbering么，outnumbering显然不是written的一个伴随结果，故排除A

allenhzkk

http://www.usee.com.tw/driven/blog_article.asp?id=7114。这里给的32的答案是D，

选E的同学你们翻译的累不累，能说服自己吗，D三个并列的因素的综合作用导致那个结果，这才是合情合理的。
而E的翻译完全就是说E正确后很无赖的翻译啊，那三个并列哈意义都没有了啊。

至于since接句子我不懂。

yinlixiao

since即使连词也是副词还是介词，做介词时，就可以加名词,为什么大家一致认为一定要加句子???

singdeath

我觉得逻辑意思上（结合语法上）来说，D和E都有问题：
    

D 是比较贴近正确的逻辑意思的，很明显，erosion，prehistoric movement和volcanic activity是同类事物，可以构成并列，而“由于火山作用上升的含金子的河床”没有“火山活动”更贴切。而且，注意，that引导的定语从句谓语用的是thrust，复数，修饰前面三个名词，说明erosion，prehistoric movement和volcanic activity的共同作用是河床上升，紧接着一个伴随结果
        putting gold literally within
reach for.

    

但D的不足之处就是since，引导原因状语从句时是连词，应该跟句子，这里去掉that就好了。Since做介词时表示“自从“
        。还有within the reach of sb是固定搭配。