ChaseDream
搜索
返回列表 发新帖
楼主: 星点秋雨
打印 上一主题 下一主题

[录取汇报] Stanford Finmath VS CMU MSCF 该选择哪个呢?(附背景)[2.23更新]

[复制链接]
81#
发表于 2012-2-23 22:13:18 | 只看该作者
我有一个CMU pitt再读的,说找intern的情况整体不错,当然具体就不清楚了,也要看楼主想将来干啥,我觉得LZ由信心的话就stanford吧,按之前人说的,貌似对长期发展不错,短期的话CMU的回报率真的很高,至少新加坡这边投行的ST很认CMU。
BTW 拜一下LZ的BG之后好奇一下,top5都是哪些啊,以前常听说top4的。。。。。。。还有特别想八卦LZ的专业
-- by 会员 wzglljp (2012/2/23 16:07:20)


新加坡这边投行的ST很认CMU?真的?
-- by 会员 lsymichael (2012/2/23 21:09:11)

barcaps FX 的一个AVP对去年ISE毕业到CMU读书的某牛说的,u know him!
82#
发表于 2012-2-23 22:23:46 | 只看该作者
港校表示这么多年没有听说过我们学校任何人cgpa过3.9的飘过。。。3.8就绝对是神级了。。。fail了才能重修,而且会把fail的成绩计入gpa(0.0/4.0),而且重修的时候成绩会降一档给。每个课前5-10%给A,5-20%给A-(3.7),20-35%给B+(3.3)。伤不起啊。
83#
发表于 2012-2-23 22:46:23 | 只看该作者
我听说了。。。中大给分比较不厚道
84#
发表于 2012-2-23 23:09:32 | 只看该作者
我有一个CMU pitt再读的,说找intern的情况整体不错,当然具体就不清楚了,也要看楼主想将来干啥,我觉得LZ由信心的话就stanford吧,按之前人说的,貌似对长期发展不错,短期的话CMU的回报率真的很高,至少新加坡这边投行的ST很认CMU。
BTW 拜一下LZ的BG之后好奇一下,top5都是哪些啊,以前常听说top4的。。。。。。。还有特别想八卦LZ的专业
-- by 会员 wzglljp (2012/2/23 16:07:20)



新加坡这边投行的ST很认CMU?真的?
-- by 会员 lsymichael (2012/2/23 21:09:11)


barcaps FX 的一个AVP对去年ISE毕业到CMU读书的某牛说的,u know him!
-- by 会员 wzglljp (2012/2/23 22:13:18)

HAHA... I know him... he is good...
85#
发表于 2012-2-23 23:32:16 | 只看该作者
闲着无聊 看看CD
建议CMU
他的名气在投行界比stanford强 特别是quant上。
最重要的是 楼主是录取在NYC,更应该选择CMU。找实习 听seminar,network都方便。
美国这边的人申请金融工程的话, 有CMU了 就不怎么等别的学校了。。
-- by 会员 justyn73 (2012/2/23 12:25:21)






恐怕是因为这些人当时大部分申请的学校里面最好的也就是CMU了
-- by 会员 1dong2f (2012/2/23 14:29:38)





恩 Stanford NYU Princeton 录取难度都比CMU大 .... 那个Brauch 也很恐怖
-- by 会员 shinliu53 (2012/2/23 17:11:02)



selectivity : Princeton > = Stanford > Baruch/NYU/CMU > the rest of MFE programs (MIT IS NOT MFE) ....   VOTE FOR STANDFORD AGAIN !!!
-- by 会员 dafasod (2012/2/23 17:34:36)



不过话说去年CMU applicant number已经涨到了1100+
86#
发表于 2012-2-24 00:04:05 | 只看该作者
https://www.quantnet.com/mfe-admission-numbers/
-- by 会员 dafasod (2012/2/23 19:46:06)


厄 这个数据也不完全能看出来吧。。。虽然stanford数字是比较少 但是它家太注重数学了耶 基本只招数学的吧??
-- by 会员 lsymichael (2012/2/23 21:20:57)



我又2了...不是学纯数学 没有sub 也伸了
87#
发表于 2012-2-24 00:46:27 | 只看该作者
https://www.quantnet.com/mfe-admission-numbers/
-- by 会员 dafasod (2012/2/23 19:46:06)



厄 这个数据也不完全能看出来吧。。。虽然stanford数字是比较少 但是它家太注重数学了耶 基本只招数学的吧??
-- by 会员 lsymichael (2012/2/23 21:20:57)




我又2了...不是学纯数学 没有sub 也伸了
-- by 会员 shinliu53 (2012/2/24 0:04:05)

我知道一个拿到的牛牛 就是读计算金融的。。。在数学系下面了。。。差不多 (他又要说躺着中枪了)
88#
发表于 2012-2-24 03:16:28 | 只看该作者
I'm a current student at Stanford MSFM program. Last year I got offer from NYU CMU and Stanford. If you let me choose again, I will  still choose Stanford.

1 MSFMat Stanford is a small program,with less competition. With Stanford's reputation, you can get even more interviews than CMU or NYU student. cuz there are only less than 15 persons competing with you at Stanford MSFM. In NYU or CMU, you will be faced with competition with 30 or 80 persons and many of they have had several years full time experience.
2 Once you get the interview, whether you can get a offer is totally dependent on you own knowledge or your preparation. It has nothing to do with what's your program. The interviewer only care about your own ability, not where you come from.
3 Do not believe the statistical result of each program. It stands for nothing. And as far as I know, until now, students from CMU who have got summer intern offer are mostly those who have full time experience before.

So it really doesn't matter which program you choose. The key is you try your best to prepare for interview and perform your best in the interview. I choose Stanford is simply because I want to meet different people here, not just business guys. And now I know lots of guys who are passionate about starting their own businesses here. You can see and feel the unique entrepreneurs spirits at Stanford.
-- by 会员 soulofloving (2012/2/23 16:48:32)


very very true
89#
发表于 2012-2-24 03:18:51 | 只看该作者
我有一个CMU pitt再读的,说找intern的情况整体不错,当然具体就不清楚了,也要看楼主想将来干啥,我觉得LZ由信心的话就stanford吧,按之前人说的,貌似对长期发展不错,短期的话CMU的回报率真的很高,至少新加坡这边投行的ST很认CMU。
BTW 拜一下LZ的BG之后好奇一下,top5都是哪些啊,以前常听说top4的。。。。。。。还有特别想八卦LZ的专业
-- by 会员 wzglljp (2012/2/23 16:07:20)


新加坡这边投行的ST很认CMU?真的?
-- by 会员 lsymichael (2012/2/23 21:09:11)


那是因为CMU申那面的人多 stanford基本没什么人投那面 如果投的话肯定不会比CMU的牌子效果差
90#
发表于 2012-2-24 03:21:20 | 只看该作者
I'm a current student at Stanford MSFM program. Last year I got offer from NYU CMU and Stanford. If you let me choose again, I will  still choose Stanford.

1 MSFMat Stanford is a small program,with less competition. With Stanford's reputation, you can get even more interviews than CMU or NYU student. cuz there are only less than 15 persons competing with you at Stanford MSFM. In NYU or CMU, you will be faced with competition with 30 or 80 persons and many of they have had several years full time experience.
2 Once you get the interview, whether you can get a offer is totally dependent on you own knowledge or your preparation. It has nothing to do with what's your program. The interviewer only care about your own ability, not where you come from.
3 Do not believe the statistical result of each program. It stands for nothing. And as far as I know, until now, students from CMU who have got summer intern offer are mostly those who have full time experience before.

So it really doesn't matter which program you choose. The key is you try your best to prepare for interview and perform your best in the interview. I choose Stanford is simply because I want to meet different people here, not just business guys. And now I know lots of guys who are passionate about starting their own businesses here. You can see and feel the unique entrepreneurs spirits at Stanford.
-- by 会员 soulofloving (2012/2/23 16:48:32)



very very true
-- by 会员 comesagain (2012/2/24 3:16:28)



"And as far as I know, until now, students from CMU who have got summer intern offer are mostly those who have full time experience before."

这个必须为CMU正名,我认识的几个无W\E CMU童鞋都是牛 intern offer
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立即注册

Mark一下! 看一下! 顶楼主! 感谢分享! 快速回复:

近期活动

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()

手机版|ChaseDream|GMT+8, 2025-5-4 23:16
京公网安备11010202008513号 京ICP证101109号 京ICP备12012021号

ChaseDream 论坛

© 2003-2025 ChaseDream.com. All Rights Reserved.

返回顶部