gwd-6-20

麦麦麦

谢谢楼上的各位.终于知道了B为啥不好.

电脑里在放的音乐和mindfree图里跳舞的节奏一样,,,于是盯着图看傻了....跳得不错~

FionaLiang

这道题，经过比较，我选对了D，但是我对D的削弱作用还有一些疑问：

D说Many Levaskans 把别的长期存款挪到了这个special accounts里，但是many并不是all，甚至连most都不是，也就是说，可能还有很多人是真的因为special accounts而增加了长期存款的，可能这个special accounts还是起到了作用的。

所以我觉得，D并不见得能起到削弱的作用........

请NN一定指点！！！谢谢！！！

FionaLiang

自己顶一下，实在很困惑，估计会影响我做其它题的思路......

Victorlb

Fiona, "weaken" is not equal to "deny" or "oppose",I think.

What you concerned about is why D cannot "deny" the argument , but not "weaken".

For example,

Argument: You are late for work again , you must want to quit.

Weaken:   There was a traffic jam on your way to work.

(But it cannot deny the possibility that you may want to quit.)

D gives us a consideration that partial money accumulated in the special accounts are from

the transfer, but not from the new savings. So it weakens the argument.

FionaLiang

以下是引用Victorlb在2006-3-12 13:57:00的发言：

Fiona, "weaken" is not equal to "deny" or "oppose",I think.

What you concerned about is why D cannot "deny" the argument , but not "weaken".

For example,

Argument: You are late for work again , you must want to quit.

Weaken:   There was a traffic jam on your way to work.

(But it cannot deny the possibility that you may want to quit.)

D gives us a consideration that partial money accumulated in the special accounts are from

the transfer, but not from the new savings. So it weakens the argument.

想想......

好像的确有道理！

谢谢Victorlb ！！

vicomte

想想还是D好些

原计划是要鼓励居民增加savings，但是D指出尽管特殊帐户的钱增加了，但是不是新存款，是存款转存款的状况。

B说L城的那些有另一种帐户的那部分工人不能从特殊帐户获利，但是可能还有更多没有另一种帐户的工人可以从特殊帐户获利。

wkw5336280

请问C是什么意思，哪位帮忙翻译一下，特别那个income bracket of。。。

nuannuanyu

A为什么不对啊？钱存进去又取出来了啊？

michaellu97

赫赫  D

znlhy

A没有说那些withdraw是65岁以前发生的