gwd 4-2

小蓓

нандин

看来看去 A  最好

having 必错 在白勇语法里 呵呵

manfromars

A中的and who，这是定语从句的并列？第一次看到这种形式

bigskings

以下是引用нандин在2007-8-13 21:56:00的发言：

看来看去 A  最好

having 必错 在白勇语法里 呵呵

白勇语法是完成时的having错。这里是有！

你理解错啦！！

这题我选了having！！

虽然我现在觉得选a比b好。但我认为这里不是having有歧义

应该还是主要是平行的问题

lulu_odin

carriewongun

前人的讨论果然非常精彩，但我还有一些异议，欢迎指教：

Q2:

In Greek theology the supreme being was Esaugetu Emissee (Master of Breath), who dwelt in an upper realm in which the sky was the floor, and who had the power to give and to take away the breath of life.

A. in which the sky was the floor, and who had the power to give and to take （很明显是who and who的并列结构。可是关于并列，如果是二者并列不是不需要逗号吗？ie A and B.   如果是三者并列才是有逗号的，ie A, B, and C呀？     我觉得这是A选项的一个小flaw.)

B. where the sky was the floor, having the power to give and to take (确实是having离它的主语太远了，会造成歧义。)

C. whose floor was the sky, and who has the power of giving and of taking （has.  不多说了。另外whose引领这个从句意思也太不靠谱了）

D. in which the sky was the floor, with the power of giving and taking （其实with可以跳跃修饰，所以这里错不在它。应该是the power of sb. to do sth.的习惯用法问题。）

E. whose floor was the sky, having the power to give and take（见B，C的解释）

总的来讲还是要选a.

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-7-25 4:04:26编辑过]

carriewongun

以下是引用vicomte在2006-5-30 10:26:00的发言：

D里面用with为什么会有歧异呢

本来with就是可以用来跳跃修饰的，从逻辑上讲，floor也不会拥有power啊

同意这里关于with的说法！

carriewongun

以下是引用duankaicheng在2006-11-2 20:49:00的发言：

想问一下A中的" to give and to take away"中的第二个TO是不是多余的啊, 我觉得好象是多余的, 如果去掉的话会有什么样的错误呢?

同问。

还想扩展地问一下，并列结构里到底哪些成分是可以省略的呢？

benzine

Some learning...

power of doing sth和power to do sth的区别：

power of doing sth，可以是指doing sth会带来的影响（Influence），如：the power of his writing，

power to do sth是指有do sth的权力（Right/Authority），如：本题中的power to give and to take...

tianyi_2003

以下是引用carriewongun在2008-7-25 3:32:00的发言：

前人的讨论果然非常精彩，但我还有一些异议，欢迎指教：

Q2:

In Greek theology the supreme being was Esaugetu Emissee (Master of Breath), who dwelt in an upper realm in which the sky was the floor, and who had the power to give and to take away the breath of life.

A. in which the sky was the floor, and who had the power to give and to take （很明显是who and who的并列结构。可是关于并列，如果是二者并列不是不需要逗号吗？ie A and B.   如果是三者并列才是有逗号的，ie A, B, and C呀？     我觉得这是A选项的一个小flaw.)

这里的逗号我百思不得其解，为什么要加上逗号，逗号是不能随便添加的，只要不对大多是绝对错误,难道大家不觉得这里有什么问题吗？？？求教求教