【每日逻辑链练习贴】【逻辑3-2】

fox0923

kelly，我第2题选了B，后来看了C也明白了为什么选C，但是我从官方网copy过来的C选项的解释看不太懂。以下是C的解释：

{C. This method does not account for both the potential influence of chemicals from the road's composition and chemicals from rain residue on the surface of the bike tire. Simply because the manufacturer used or did not use chemicals from the road's composition within the bike's frame does not enable us to conclude that the same chemicals will or will not have a corrosive effect if applied to the bike's tires. In other words, testing effects on the bike's frame is entirely unrelated to testing effects on the bike's tires as these two components (i.e., frame and tire) are made of entirely different materials.}

上面这段话有红色highlight的部分说我们两个方面都要考虑到：1. chemicals from the road's composition 2. chemicals from rain residue on the surface of the bike tire
记得我们平常作weaken/strengthen题目，只需要weaken/strengthen其中一个premise就好了，没必要两个一起。所以我在想，这种想法是不是只有在做evaluation题目的时候才考虑所有的premise？还是说这道题的解释可以忽略不看呢？
bat大师，给出个招！！

superbat28

After thousands of miles of use, the tread on many bike tires wears down. One common theory about why tires wear down contends that the perpetual friction and heat generated by the contact between the tire and pavement erode the material on the surface of the tire. However, a local scientist who is also an avid cyclist proposed a new theory for why bike tires wear down. This scientist contended that chemicals from the road's composition and chemicals from rain residue wore down the surface of the tire.

这道题啊？~呃呃呃~我觉得我好就不看英文了，脑袋跟不上了T T~~~我感觉就把我的思路说了呗~

它是因果型结论啊~相当于对一个现象给出了两个解释~
解释一，【是骑车过程中产生的热】
解释二，【是道路和雨水中的chemical导致的】

那evaluate的话，就是去看到底是解释一，还是解释二呗~
那就是找一个选项，那个选项的感觉是：“有一无二的过程时候造成了tire损毁”，或者是“有二无一的时候造成了tire损毁”

我觉得这个感觉~应该很好prephase吧~~~~
然后带着这个感觉，看选项，就是C啊~~~

fox0923

After thousands of miles of use, the tread on many bike tires wears down. One common theory about why tires wear down contends that the perpetual friction and heat generated by the contact between the tire and pavement erode the material on the surface of the tire. However, a local scientist who is also an avid cyclist proposed a new theory for why bike tires wear down. This scientist contended that chemicals from the road's composition and chemicals from rain residue wore down the surface of the tire.

这道题啊？~呃呃呃~我觉得我好就不看英文了，脑袋跟不上了T T~~~我感觉就把我的思路说了呗~

它是因果型结论啊~相当于对一个现象给出了两个解释~
解释一，【是骑车过程中产生的热】
解释二，【是道路和雨水中的chemical导致的】

那evaluate的话，就是去看到底是解释一，还是解释二呗~
那就是找一个选项，那个选项的感觉是：“有一无二的过程时候造成了tire损毁”，或者是“有二无一的时候造成了tire损毁”

我觉得这个感觉~应该很好prephase吧~~~~
然后带着这个感觉，看选项，就是C啊~~~

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/9/19 23:13:36)

恩那，明白了，糊糊也明白为什么选C，就是看了网站的英文解释有些不明白，所以才来确认一下，看来这种题目和我们平时做的strengthen/weaken一样的，取一就好了，不用管别的。那我就忽略那个官网解释了。谢谢bat了~

superbat28

After thousands of miles of use, the tread on many bike tires wears down. One common theory about why tires wear down contends that the perpetual friction and heat generated by the contact between the tire and pavement erode the material on the surface of the tire. However, a local scientist who is also an avid cyclist proposed a new theory for why bike tires wear down. This scientist contended that chemicals from the road's composition and chemicals from rain residue wore down the surface of the tire.

这道题啊？~呃呃呃~我觉得我好就不看英文了，脑袋跟不上了T T~~~我感觉就把我的思路说了呗~

它是因果型结论啊~相当于对一个现象给出了两个解释~
解释一，【是骑车过程中产生的热】
解释二，【是道路和雨水中的chemical导致的】

那evaluate的话，就是去看到底是解释一，还是解释二呗~
那就是找一个选项，那个选项的感觉是：“有一无二的过程时候造成了tire损毁”，或者是“有二无一的时候造成了tire损毁”

我觉得这个感觉~应该很好prephase吧~~~~
然后带着这个感觉，看选项，就是C啊~~~

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2011/9/19 23:13:36)

恩那，明白了，糊糊也明白为什么选C，就是看了网站的英文解释有些不明白，所以才来确认一下，看来这种题目和我们平时做的strengthen/weaken一样的，取一就好了，不用管别的。那我就忽略那个官网解释了。谢谢bat了~

-- by 会员 fox0923 (2011/9/20 1:38:38)

其实我是转不动了T T~fox姐不要想太多哈~就找到最直接，切中要害的逻辑感觉就好。。
bat好困啊。。bat要睡觉。。。T T～～～

ykelly123

3.Automation, the trademark of a modern economy, is essential to maximizing a country's economic production while minimizing its costs. Health care executives want to increase revenues while reducing costs. Consequently, they propose significantly greater automation of health care. Yet, this should be rejected. Radical automation of health care would cause patients to lose trust in the system as the health care they would receive would lack the in-person care that studies show patients desire.
Which of the following expresses the main point of the argument?

A)  Health care should not be heavily automated
B)  atients desire customized in-person care
C)  Trends in the general economy do not apply to the health care industry
D)  Health care executives are becoming too greedy
E)  Due to economic forces, automation of health care is eventually inevitable


Answer: A
这题为什么选A不选C类？？？

fox0923

3.Automation, the trademark of a modern economy, is essential to maximizing a country's economic production while minimizing its costs. Health care executives want to increase revenues while reducing costs. Consequently, they propose significantly greater automation of health care. Yet, this should be rejected. Radical automation of health care would cause patients to lose trust in the system as the health care they would receive would lack the in-person care that studies show patients desire.
Which of the following expresses the main point of the argument?

A)  Health care should not be heavily automated
B)  atients desire customized in-person care
C)  Trends in the general economy do not apply to the health care industry
D)  Health care executives are becoming too greedy
E)  Due to economic forces, automation of health care is eventually inevitable


Answer: A
这题为什么选A不选C类？？？

-- by 会员 ykelly123 (2011/9/20 3:28:25)

kelly，我觉得这道题应该是
Premise：automation可以increase revenue while reducing cost。
Premise：automation会降低in-person的treatment，所以让病人对这种新型的system没有信心。
Conclusion：这个automation在health care里不适用。
Main Point：就是应该涵括这两个premise的就对了，A里面说Health care should not be heavily automated，其实就是总结原文结论。而C中Trends in the general economy do not apply to the health care industry，这个只能被看作是个infer吧，对于全文的总结没有起到决定的作用。其中的trends还有general economy并没有提到，文中说的是modern economy，至于这种trend，文中没有详细提出trend到底是指什么。
所以C给我的感觉是比较模糊的，并没有围绕health care和automation这个很局限的话题来说。

ykelly123

恩，所以短文中提到过的conclusion也可以作为答案，
不像weakening或strengthening文中提到过的premise就不能算答案了

daisyの小夢想

1. 22s
The computer scientists have to pursuit bussiness achievements and make profitable products.
Thus the scientists are losing their creative aspects.
Assumption:
making profitable products can not have creative elements.
C

2.48s
Some claim that friction and heat wear down tires.
Others claim that chemicals from the road's composition and chemicals from rain residue wear down tires.
Evaluation:
Will tires wear down on the matter without any road's compostition and chemicals from rain residue?
B

3.47s
BG:some think that to reduce costs, the health care should increase automation.
Premise:If the automation become radical, the public will not trust the system because the health care they received will not studies personal desires.
Conclusion:
The automation should not increase.
Main point: like the conclustion
A

4. 45s
The complaints about SS from students have declined.
The school assumes that it's because they have provided a softer running surface that absorbs much of the SS.
Weaken:
Other factors
C

daisyの小夢想

噢噢 从今天起一定要坚持每天做逻辑^^ 大家监督我哈！！

superbat28

噢噢 从今天起一定要坚持每天做逻辑^^ 大家监督我哈！！

-- by 会员 daisyの小夢想 (2011/9/20 10:26:40)

I see, I see~~~haha