1. 45s The major issue is not that the nonsmokers are harmed by the smokers' smoking behavior but that businessman's freedom to determine its sales behavior is violated. Strengthen: 政府监管会影响商人的自由，商人无法在限定范围内作出自由决策。
2. 36s More of whom had taken anti-seasickness medicine reported seasickness than those who had not taken the medicine. Conclusion: The medicine is not recommended to eat. Weaken: Those who had taken the medicine are atually much more weaker and more easy to have seasickness.
3. 43s On foreign-made parts, you never know which type of parts are more liable and have higher quality. So you should choose brand-name parts by Clark. Assumption: Clark is more reliable.
4. 65s The increase in death rate of asthma among people is not caused by fewer death record and air polluction. Thus, it's caused by the use of bronchial inhalers by asthma sufferers. Strengthen: a. It's also not caused by other reasons. b. Suffers who use bronchial inhalers are more likely to die than suffers who do not use them.
It is clear, then, that despite claims by drug companies that clinical tests show the contrary, people would be better off not taking anti-seasickness medications. 直译： 很明显，尽管药品生产商声明此实验的结论----人们不吃抗晕药物会更好---是与生产商相反的。
1.45s
BG: Government established a law to designate the smoker and non-smoker sectors.
Conclusion: Criticize the law by claiming that it interferes right and privacy.
Principle/Assumption: C the right of private sector is more important.
2. 40s
BG: A survey is conducted on the ferry passengers.
Premise: People who have taken pills reported more symptom of seasickness than people without pills.
CC: So the pills are useless.
Weaken: People who do not take pills don't have the problem of seasickness at all. or D.
3. 45s
CC: Our car parts are the best. We passed through even the toughest test.
PM: You cannot tell if foreign-made car parts are good or not and you have to take the risk of repair them with huge cost.
CHOOSE US!
Assumption: 我在A,D之间犹豫了。。。求破。A是肿么回事~
4.看了两遍。。。
BG: Despite the improvement of treatment in asthma, the death rate still increases in the recent years.
Reasoning1: The surveys about death rate are more accurate than before.
R2: Urban pollution increases.
PM: In cities with good health care and little pollution, asthma still increases.
CC: Instead, the increase is due to an inhaler.
Weaken/ do not support: A
5. 30s
There is no hope that a new opened ice cream shop is going to gain revenue. And we should not approve the business loan application.
Reasoning1 : Winter is cold, people won't buy ice-cream
Evidence1: With 10000 population, there's only one ice-cream shop.
Evidence2：Even without competition, the only icecream shop experienced a reduction in its revenue.
Attack:
1. In cold winter people could also enjoy icecream indoors.
2. The only existing shop chain is of bad quality and the branches are located too close near eath other, which are the main reasons of the decrease in revenue.
3. Or the whole city is going through a economic depression.
京公网安备11010202008513号 京ICP证101109号 京ICP备12012021号
楼主
发表于 2011-9-8 16:11:53
时隔3周没有做逻辑链 终于回归了 太开心了~~~!