探讨：GWD-9-5

而今迈步从头越

第6题偶也选C啊！

skidals

以下是引用而今迈步从头越在2005-4-27 16:15:00的发言：
第6题偶也选C啊！

谢谢斑斑支持

jones79

The

(30)   commodities produced in these

zones were extracted, processed,

and transported entirely by members

of a single group.

第6题问题的前提是: the problem of different resource distribution 在vertical economy与trade network之间的区别,上面感觉好像并没有说明与resourse distribution有关

偶认为还是选d

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-4-28 16:56:33编辑过]

ah_eric

E 是他们其中之一的方式，但纵观全文都是说这些ANDean如何用VERTICALECONOMY在不同高度建立PRODUCTIONZONE，而不主要借助外部TRade，controled by single group 在文中非常重要

leisure1221

4567题的答案应该是 b,a,c,d 其中56题答案有争议， 但5，6的其他选项都有各自的明显错误，通过仔细定位和比较可以明确的排除。

windflower560

以下是引用ziwingfong在2005-2-13 0:04:00的发言：

GWD-9-Q6:

The passage suggests that as a way of addressing the problem of different resource distribution in the preindustrial world, the practice of vertical economy differed from the use of long-distance trade networks in that vertical economy allowed

A. commodities to reach the end consumer faster

B. a wide variety of agricultural goods to reach the end consumer

C. a single group to maintain control over the production process

D. greater access to commodities from lower, warmer climatic zones

E. greater use of self-sufficient agricultural techniques

答案是D，为什么不选C呢？

为什么B不对？In most of the pre-industrial world, the problem of different resource distribution was resolved by long-distance trade networks over which the end consumer exercised little control.

谢谢

billion

Q5: E
According to the passage, the inhabitants of the Andean highlands resolved the problem
of unequal resource distribution primarily in which of the following ways?

A. Following self-sufficient agricultural practices （Andean inhabitants 和其他Intar groups 都是self-sufficient，此选项不体现Andean方法的特殊性）
B. Increasing commodity production from the ecological zones in the highland----------MUST BE WRONG
basins
C. Increasing their reliance on long-distance trade networks---------------MUST BE WRONG
D. Establishing satellite communities throughout the Andean highlands
E. Establishing production forces in ecological zones beyond their parent
communities （正确选项）

Q6: E
The passage suggests that as a way of addressing the problem of different resource distribution in the preindustrial world, the practice of vertical economy differed from the use of long-distance trade networks in that vertical economy allowed

A. commodities to reach the end consumer faster （文中没说）
B. a wide variety of agricultural goods to reach the end consumer （文中没说）
C. a single group to maintain control over the production process （netwok 和 vertical 都可以具备此特征）
D. greater access to commodities from lower, warmer climatic zones （network 和 vertical 都可以 access to lower, warmer climatic zones，但文章并没有针对其 access 的程度进行比较）
E. greater use of self-sufficient agricultural techniques （这是 network 和 vertical economy 的本质区别，是正确选项）

xinfaxian

以下是引用davidcopper在2004-12-22 10:46:00的发言：
A应该更好，原因一，A选项中的following。本来self-sufficient，但是受地理限制，然而还是仅仅部分依靠贸易，更主要的还是self-sufficient（因为希望更多control），只是拓宽了ss的地理界域而已，不能说你在这里种地是ss，到别处种地就不是ss了。文中有两处转折，所以转回去了。原因二，产供销一条龙，还不ss？原因三，E选项的beyond反。

强烈支持。分析地太透彻了！

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-6-6 1:07:18编辑过]

xinfaxian

以下是引用liu_9000在2005-1-6 18:14:00的发言：

这里有个对self-sufficient的理解问题. 不知道从高山跑到海边去种地算不算self-sufficient.

算，当然算。

remona9t

本来第6题选C,看了楼上的讨论，却时觉得C存在一个争议：即production的范围包括什么，仔细的看了原文，认为production应该包括原文所说的extracted, processed, transported,即萃取，加工，运输，这些都应该包括在生产的范围内，即production process.

至于D的错误，我认为access to commodities from lower, warmer climatic zones是两种方法的共同目的，文中只是比较了两种方法的不同，并没有明确指出，vertical economy能够greater access--就像57楼说的一样。

open to discussion