PrepCR101

sunspirit2011

101.    (31700-!-item-!-188;#058&006145)    (GWD 3-Q38/prep 2-6 different type)


Two computer companies, Garnet and Renco, each pay Salcor to provide health insurance for their employees.  Because early treatment of high cholesterol can prevent strokes that would otherwise occur several years later, Salcor encourages Garnet employees to have their cholesterol levels tested and to obtain early treatment for high cholesterol.  Renco employees generally remain with Renco only for a few years, however.  Therefore, Salcor lacks any financial incentive to provide similar encouragement to Renco employees.


Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?


A. Early treatment of high cholesterol does not eliminate the possibility of a stroke later in life.
B. People often obtain early treatment for high cholesterol on their own.
C. Garnet hires a significant number of former employees of Renco.
D. Renco and Garnet have approximately the same number of employees.
E. Renco employees are not, on average, significantly younger than Garnet employees.


答案是C


我的理解：
文章说：因为尽早对高胆固醇进行治疗能够防止一些年后中风的发生，S保险公司鼓励G公司雇员检查胆固醇水平并及早治疗高胆固醇。R公司雇员通常只在公司呆几年，所以S公司缺少经济动机去鼓励R公司员工进行胆固醇水平检查和高胆固醇治疗。
A：尽早治疗高胆固醇并不会减少今后中风的可能性。【如果治疗不会减少中风可能性，S公司就更加没有动机了，我觉得是加强】
B：人们常常自己去尽早治疗高胆固醇。【文章说雇员，这里说人们，讨论范围扩大；人们自己治不治和S公司的决策没有关系】
C：G公司雇佣了非常多的R公司以前的雇员。【我不理解：G公司雇佣了非常多R公司以前的雇员，和S公司对R公司的什么动机有关吗？】
D：R和G两公司的雇员人数差不多一样。【雇员人数，无关内容】
E：平均上来说，R公司的雇员并不比G公司雇员年轻很多。【我选这个选项的，因为排除到后来就剩它了=.=!】


求教高手：C选项如何解释？我的理解和排除理由是否有问题？快二战了，遇到题目百思不得其解，若能解答，不胜感激！

sdcar2010

Well, because if G hires many R's former employees, then S has to take care of R's former employees eventually. So S has a financial incentive to diagonose future risks in R's employees now before it becomes too late when R's employees jumped to G.

sunspirit2011

3Q!

索索michelle

Well, because if G hires many R's former employees, then S has to take care of R's former employees eventually. So S has a financial incentive to diagonose future risks in R's employees now before it becomes too late when R's employees jumped to G.

-- by 会员 sdcar2010 (2011/8/30 9:31:44)

我也正纳闷这奇怪的答案呢~~楼主解答很清楚哈~~~3X！！！

balapupu

果然还是Sdcar大神厉害哈~~~~这个思路好奇特。。。

donkid

牛。确实是为防跳槽才不做的，反正你跳到那边会做这个检查，我就不用浪费钱了。就说明没钱时不一定成立的。

喵鲶小馨

sdcar 厉害饿！

lxtaurus19

我对题目和C选项的理解：
G和R都付给S钱，S提供这两个公司雇员中风的保险赔偿。题目是从S保险公司的经济利益角度出发的。S鼓励G给员工做检查，因为早发现早治疗就不会发展到中风，S就可以减少给G员工的中风赔偿。但是S也有动机和理由要鼓励R给员工做检查，因为（如C选项所言）很多R的员工都跑到G工作，如果这部分人在R没有检查出来病情，到了G就中风，那么S还是要给这部分人赔偿的。

lxtaurus19

所以，和跳槽不跳槽没有关系。要注意是从保险公司S的经济利益角度出发。

GWinner

我对题目和C选项的理解：
G和R都付给S钱，S提供这两个公司雇员中风的保险赔偿。题目是从S保险公司的经济利益角度出发的。S鼓励G给员工做检查，因为早发现早治疗就不会发展到中风，S就可以减少给G员工的中风赔偿。但是S也有动机和理由要鼓励R给员工做检查，因为（如C选项所言）很多R的员工都跑到G工作，如果这部分人在R没有检查出来病情，到了G就中风，那么S还是要给这部分人赔偿的。

-- by 会员 lxtaurus19 (2012/3/9 9:09:09)

同意~注意关键词financial incentive, 以及前面所说S公司是做health insurance
关键还是要放在S公司的经济利益上来看