哪一家的MBA排名更为接近我们的真实情况？

ykcarrera · 发表于 2011-7-29 15:56:16

I know for everyone it vastly differs,but how can we believe such a ranking like Financial Times?
I've recently bought a magazine called "Which MBA?" published by The Economist,the ranking it posts could be even strange.
How about rankings from BW?WSJ?

说白了，哪个排名相对靠谱些？

OxSead · 发表于 2011-7-29 16:03:10

In general, US News > BW > FT > all others

davidsiqi · 发表于 2011-7-29 16:11:41

其实排名看看就好
top7top15top30变化不大也比较稳定

ykcarrera · 发表于 2011-7-29 16:13:34

其实排名看看就好
top7top15top30变化不大也比较稳定

-- by 会员 davidsiqi (2011/7/29 16:11:41)

FT的top 7有HKUST==！

Dharma001 · 发表于 2011-7-29 16:21:55

US News 最符合大众认知，由于其中很多数据都是有学校自己提供，而且权重的调节有太多空间操控，受到很多专业机构和人员质疑（其实哪个都有）
BW 比较受专业人士看好，因为它是纯客户（学生+雇主）满意度调查而非看量化数据。不过最新一期的排名把SMU Cox放在Tuck，Yale， Cornell，Stern前面让其受到无数质疑
FT的感觉是为了global而global，排名很让人看不懂，尤其是比较美国和Global的program。个人觉得参考意义不是很大。
WSJ是只看雇主的打分，容易bias（大公司来学校招生的人多数校友），早都停止排名了。

个人觉得US News和BW比较靠谱~~当然，每个人心中都有一个自己的学校排名。

davidsiqi · 发表于 2011-7-29 16:24:16

FT的top 7有HKUST==！
这样= =~
FT么忽略好了

nevermindband · 发表于 2011-7-30 12:34:54

個人推介 www.poetsandquants.com 的排名:

1. Harvard Business School Boston, MA
2. Stanford Business School Stanford, CA
3. Chicago (Booth) Chicago, IL
4. Pennsylvania (Wharton) Philadelphia, PA
5. Columbia Business School New York, NY
6. Dartmouth (Tuck) Hanover, NH
7. Northwestern (Kellogg) Evanston, IL
8. MIT (Sloan) Cambridge, MA
9. California (Haas) Berkeley, CA
10. Duke (Fuqua) Durham, NC
11. Virginia (Darden) Charlottesville, VA
12. New York (Stern) New York, NY
13. Michigan (Ross) Ann Arbor, MI
14. Yale School of Mgt. New Haven, CT
15. Cornell (Johnson) Ithaca, NY

windmaple · 发表于 2011-7-30 13:25:29

Financial Times is published by UKer (still wonder why HKUST is ranked higher?)

You can basically ignore it if you are interested in US schools

JonFrank · 发表于 2011-7-31 15:29:14

Hello my friend. This is the way that we see rankings—for schools in the US, we like US World and News Report. Those are the rankings that folks in the US pay the most attention to—nobody cares about the WSJ or Businessweek. Now, the only problem is that US World and News Report doesn’t include international schools. So that is why we DO like Financial Times rankings. Not because they are correct with regard to US schools, but they do give a good sense for international programs. So between US World and News Report, and Financial Times, you will have everything you need. Those are the only two rankings that we pay any attention to anyway…

Jon Frank
HBS 2005

[排名] 哪一家的MBA排名更为接近我们的真实情况？

所属分类: 商学院申请

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()

浏览过的版块