偶尔在网上翻到一个2007年的欧洲mba排名,拿出来给大家看看

Lei2011

pursueMBA 2010,
数据准不准我比你更清楚好不好，IESE 官网上post的数据是2009年的placement，businessweek上的是2010年的。

Lei2011

如果你认为businessweek是在忽悠人，那我也没办法

38383388

LS的你是没有做过research呢？还是故意误导？能说出你的理由吗？我觉得IESE排第五都低了呢

-- by 会员 Lei2011 (2011/7/21 15:46:16)

读MBA无非就是要个名声，校友和氛围。OX这几条都完爆IESE啊。

如果是中国人的话更是如此，虽然英国和西班牙都不好找工作，但前者是因为竞争太激烈，后者多是因为没什么可就业的地方。回国的话两者无论是认知度还是校友圈都不在一个位面上。

pursueMBA2010

I am not student from both schools. I suppose I am not bias.

1. As my understanding, class of 2009 means these student joined IESE in 2009 and will graduate in the end of 2010 or early of 2011(i am not familiar with IESE, so just from common sense); This is the 1st reason I prefer to trust that report.

2. My exp taught me to believe authority. In that case, who is the best person to know your school? I think it is your career office. That is why I never trust "so called" third-party like BW.

3. Data on Said in BW is too odd. For example, School-facilitated activities: 11 %, Graduate-facilitated activities: 9 %, No information provided by graduate: 81 %,  pls add them. The result is over 100%(101%). what happened? Although I know the career office of Said is not strong, 11% is really unbelievable, honestly(Actually, if the number is 30-40%, i think it is acceptable)

I never say IESE is not good. I know it is a top school indeed although its brand in mainland is not very strong. But from the data(not the data you show but from websites of schools), I don't know what is the obviously advantage of IESE to Said. Don't be so bias.......
Actually, I believe in EU, except Lbs and INSEAD, resources of other "top" schools are similar. This means these top schools are in the same level. It really depends on personal situation to select anyone out of them

Lei2011

LS的你是没有做过research呢？还是故意误导？能说出你的理由吗？我觉得IESE排第五都低了呢

-- by 会员 Lei2011 (2011/7/21 15:46:16)

读MBA无非就是要个Name，校友和氛围。OX这几条都完爆IESE啊。

-- by 会员 38383388 (2011/7/21 18:23:05)

这些能当饭吃吗？找不到工作有什么用？满足你的虚荣心？你是不是还没长大？在一个公司里，挣九万美元的不太可能比挣11万美元的级别高吧？

38383388

LS的你是没有做过research呢？还是故意误导？能说出你的理由吗？我觉得IESE排第五都低了呢

-- by 会员 Lei2011 (2011/7/21 15:46:16)

读MBA无非就是要个Name，校友和氛围。OX这几条都完爆IESE啊。

-- by 会员 38383388 (2011/7/21 18:23:05)

这些能当饭吃吗？找不到工作有什么用？满足你的虚荣心？你是不是还没长大？在一个公司里，挣九万美元的不太可能比挣11万美元的级别高吧？

-- by 会员 Lei2011 (2011/7/21 18:27:50)

我很好奇一个中国人- 通常还是不懂西班牙语的, 在西班牙能找到什么工作？什么公司？什么职位？ 或者说IESE在国内或香港比OX更容易找工作吗？我实在找不到理由选IESE而不选SAID

38383388

算了爱谁好谁好。。关我P事。

Lei2011

I am not student from both schools. I suppose I am not bias.

1. As my understanding, class of 2009 means these student joined IESE in 2009 and will graduate in the end of 2010 or early of 2011(i am not familiar with IESE, so just from common sense); This is the 1st reason I prefer to trust that report.

2. My exp taught me to believe authority. In that case, who is the best person to know your school? I think it is your career office. That is why I never trust "so called" third-party like BW.

3. Data on Said in BW is too odd. For example, School-facilitated activities: 11 %, Graduate-facilitated activities: 9 %, No information provided by graduate: 81 %,  pls add them. The result is over 100%(101%). what happened? Although I know the career office of Said is not strong, 11% is really unbelievable, honestly(Actually, if the number is 30-40%, i think it is acceptable)

I never say IESE is not good. I know it is a top school indeed although its brand in mainland is not very strong. But from the data(not the data you show but from websites of schools), I don't know what is the obviously advantage of IESE to Said. Don't be so bias.......
Actually, I believe in EU, except Lbs and INSEAD, resources of other "top" schools are similar. This means these top schools are in the same level. It really depends on personal situation to select anyone out of them

-- by 会员 pursueMBA2010 (2011/7/21 18:25:24)

1 class of 2009 是2009年毕业，因为我是class of 2013, 今年入学。
2 任何数据只能做参考，我知道，但IESE 和said 数据差距那么大就说明了一定的问题。 没有问题的话不可能出现那么奇怪的数据，学校也会觉得丢人。 既然这么糟糕的数据能一直在那挂着，是不是也是在said的默许之下？？
3 101%的数据很正常，四舍五入造成的。

Lei2011

算了爱谁好谁好。。关我P事。

-- by 会员 38383388 (2011/7/21 18:33:07)

你早就应该这样了。我也犯不着出来掰吃一通

38383388

嗯。没想到会有人反应这么过激，不好意思伤到您脆弱的心灵了。