prep 78 对正确答案C不理解！ 看了很多讨论帖 还是弄不明白

jianaozhonghua

78.(32009-!-item-!-188;#058&006754)



Kitchen magazine plans to license the use of its name by a line of cookware.For a magazine, licensing the use of its name for products involves some danger, since if the products disappoint consumers, the magazine's reputation suffers, with consequent reductions in circulation and advertising.However, experts have evaluated the cookware and found it superior to all other cookware advertised in Kitchen.Therefore, Kitchen can collect its licensing fee without endangering its other revenues.

The argument above assumes which of the following?



A. No other line of cookware is superior to that which will carry the Kitchen name.

B. Kitchen will not license the use of its name for any products other than the line of cookware.

C. Makers of cookware will not find Kitchen a less attractive advertising vehicle because the magazine's name is associated with a competing product.

D. Consumers who are not regular readers of Kitchen magazine will be attracted to the cookware by the Kitchen name.

E. Kitchen is one of the most prestigious cooking-related magazines.

有NN说用取非做C. 我是做逻辑只凭感觉的，给第三方造成认同感增加就support assume  造成认同感降低就weaken。  不知道用我的方法或者排除法能不能做出这道题。  不理解C为什么对。  请教NN

wangxsh

我的理解
原文的意思是杂志出版商即可以收版权费又不影响其他收入。选项C说明其他厨具品牌不会因为竞争对手的产品以杂志名字冠名而不在这个杂志上做广告。也就是说这样做will not endanger its other revenues.
请指正。

jameshzd

If you negate C, you will get  "Makers of cookware will  find Kitchen a less attractive advertising vehicle because the magazine's name is associated with a competing product " ; that is, makers of cookware who do not use the name of Kitchen magazine   are unwiilling to advertise their products  on Kitchen magazine  since this magazine is associated with their competitors resulting from licensing the use of its name for their competitors' products . In this way, although Kitchen magazine   can collect its licensing fee, it at same time will lose the adverting fees by way of losing opportunities  of leasing its advertising area by the aboved makers of cookware.

when you deal with "the necessary assumption" type of Sc, you should negate the option in order to get the right answer, no personsal feelings can be added into it. If you are not good at this type of SC, i sugggest you to take time to learn the post of (八) 逻辑入门 by Sdcar2010, trust me, you will learn a lot !

jianaozhonghua

虽然我已经时间很紧了，但是，还是试试你说的那个吧，可以给个链接么？那个什么逻辑八

jameshzd

http://forum.chasedream.com/GMAT_CR/thread-569879-1-1.html

jianaozhonghua

谢谢！  这个系列太给力了  拜读中。。  S以后我要能强悍了也用英语给人解释  哈哈哈！

jameshzd

谢谢！  这个系列太给力了  拜读中。。  S以后我要能强悍了也用英语给人解释  哈哈哈！

-- by 会员 jianaozhonghua (2011/6/28 0:20:11)

you are welcome ! These posters are really worth reading !

jianaozhonghua

感受不到necessary和sufficient的区别。求明晰！

vivian2011

这题逻辑里面作者考虑不全，只考虑了从consumer那边来的negative effects 不会有，但没有考虑到其他maker of cookware的感受