[讨论]你会什么学校? INSEAD/LBS vs DUKE/Haas

Primroseoil

first tier in Europe vs first tier US (although in the second lever of first tier)

飞雪

如果签证方面没有问题，我还是会选美国的学校，考虑到将来的就业问题就不得不考虑国内对英美学位的偏见。

其次要考虑自己的职业背景，欧洲的学校喜欢工作经验丰富，尤其强调国际工作经验，工作时间长的申请者。

Yolanda_

INSEAD is more cost effective

kathy72

HAAS，GOOD FAME AND GOOD LOCATION

joshuatree

These four top schools are all in same level in terms of academic competence and reputation. While IMHO, Haas > Insead > LBS > Duke, considering the location advantage and easiness of seeking decent jobs.

琥珀川白龙

if you choose INSEAD or LBS, you will definitely have to come back to China after graduation. Besides, INSEAD MBA is only a one-year program. I don't think I can learn as much as in a US B-school. Although located in Fountain Bleau, a romantic place, it might not be a good place to study, be it spoken English or business. Above is only my personal view, without any intent to offend anyone.

flyingpiggy

以下是引用joshuatree在2004-6-17 6:26:00的发言：
These four top schools are all in same level in terms of academic competence and reputation. While IMHO, Haas > Insead > LBS > Duke, considering the location advantage and easiness of seeking decent jobs.

Same as my ranking!

wonderingcat

INSEAD,LBS,DUKE,Haas都是很好的商学院, 同时它们也深刻反应了欧洲人与美国人对MBA学习的认识上的差异.

欧洲的商学院认为所谓的商学院就是给管理工作者一个交流的舞台, 让他们从理论到实践, 从实践到理论有新的系统的认识. 所以他们更倾向于管理工作经验丰富的人, 他们认为缺少管理经验对商学院的学习是不利的.  欧洲的商学院学习压力并不大, 他们更重视的是学生间的交流, 因而有些人称之为party-school. 这一点其实也很符合欧洲人enjoy life的生活态度.

美国的商学院更侧重于学习本生, 所以压力较大. 你享受生活的时间几乎没有. 但是鉴于美国是个移民国家, 所以找工作确实比欧洲有优势. 但是美国的商学院近年来有为了赚钱而泛滥的倾向, 其中褒贬不一, 有些学校的师资力量实在不敢恭唯.  如果你希望申请美国的商学院千万要注意这一点.

我个人认为, 选择商学院其实也是在选择一种新的生活方式. 排名固然是要考虑的因素之一,但绝对不是全部. 所以千万不要在排名里钻牛角尖! 对我个人而言, 还是希望借出国的机会去扩大眼界,体验不同的人生, 而不仅仅是在象牙塔里钻两年, 然后拿着一纸文凭去找工作.