- UID
- 551204
- 在线时间
- 小时
- 注册时间
- 2010-7-30
- 最后登录
- 1970-1-1
- 主题
- 帖子
- 性别
- 保密
|
Hi Jon, I have a question about the global MBA program in Carey business school of JHU. I was recently admitted and I really like the university's strong background and style. But I am very worried about my post-MBA opportunity since the program is very new and I am not sure about the chance it can bring me in job market. Hopefully, Carey business school will get more known by the day when I graduate, but I do not think two years are long enough for a new business school to get a much higher position in the competitive ranking. Then I am considering the offer again and again... Do you have any suggestions or information for my situation? Thanks a lot! Joe -- by 会员 snailc (2011/3/2 1:01:03)
Joe, thanks for the kind note. It would be a pleasure to help here. Carey isn’t just new my friend, it is…VERY new. Brand spanking new, as we say here in the US. I share your concern. Now two things to keep in mind though—Johns Hopkins is VERY well known here in the US. So while the MBA program isn’t well known, you will get a great deal of mileage in the states. Secondly, the JHU network is very strong, especially in certain areas (medical among others). And you will have access to that network for sure. So those are good things. Do you have any other offers? If not, I would TAKE it dude. It is surely better than nothing, and (while we would love to work with you of course) it would be a shame to redo the process—especially if you don’t have ANY guarantees that you would have much improvement to write about. Here is another thing you could do—reach out to current students. Ask them DIRECTLY what they think, whether there are jobs out there, and if they are glad that they chose to go to the program. They will be honest my friend—and they will know what is REALLY happening out there… Now. One FINAL thought for you. J Are you interested in humanistic causes, making the world a better place, etc.? Because if Carey is making a name for itself in any area, THIS is the one worth pursuing there. If that is a good fit for you, then it might make lots of sense to attend. It has much in common with Yale’s SOM. I hope this is helpful my friend, let me know what more we can do to help!
Jon Frank
-- by 会员 JonFrank (2011/3/3 9:17:08)
Hi Jon, Thanksa lot for your kind help! Your information is very important for my finalchoice. Ialso got the offer from BU and helpfully I can get admitted by CMU. Amid thethree universities, which one would you recommend for me? Below are thedetails.
In@BU with 30k/year In@JHU with 30k/year Interviewedwith CMU
Mygoal is to get a consulting job in healthcare right after MBA with along-term goal in entrepreneurship or VC. What I am really worried about atthis point is whether I can find a school that could put me at an advantage inthe job market when I graduate. I do love JHU, but I have to first survive before I carry outmy dream, you know.
Sincerely, Joe-- by 会员 snailc (2011/3/3 9:55:56)
Joe, thanks for the kind note. I would be honored to answer you here—and along the way, to help some other folks better understand the way to approach bschool selection. As you know, ever since graduating from bschool we have encouraged people to go to the best school they can get into. Now, others (typically younger applicants, even some current students) sometimes have trouble understanding this perspective. And of course, other points (scholarships, geography, etc.) are to be considered…but they aren’t NEARLY as important as going to the best school you can get into. Let me explain from my personal post-MBA experience. I recently helped a few friends of mine raise some money for a film project in the US. When they asked if I had any HBS contacts, I assumed that I wouldn’t get very far w the HBS alumni database. Why? Well, HBS isn’t known for entertainment. For entertainment, conventional wisdom would be to go to Columbia, NYU, USC, UCLA, etc. After all, HBS didn’t even offer one class in entertainment!
Ten minutes later, I found that the CEO of Sony Pictures, CEO of LionsGate, CEO of AMC Theaters (the list goes on) aaaaall went to HBS. Two days later, we had one of these dudes on the phone. J You get the idea man—we go to HBS despite the fact that they don’t have a strong “connection” to the film world. I got a plum post-MBA job in real estate from HBS, and I never took even the ONE real estate class at HBS. Besides, HBS only offers one real estate class anyway! : ) But the companies I was applying to only recruited at HBS, Stanford, and Wharton…
So don’t be lead astray! All schools of course have countless opportunities for leadership, clubs, etc. So through our years of experience (helping thousands of candidates, and my own friends who have graduated from bschool), we have found a way to keep things niiiice and simple: go to the best school you can get into. J This is far more important than scholarships, geography, “quality of teaching” etc. Take it from me—I have seen it all first-hand, literally thousands of times.
Now. To your specific case. CMU has the best reputation by far of all the schools you’ve listed. I would try to get in there. Then, we weigh BU versus JH. But lets shoot for CMU if we can dude! And $30K should NEVER enter into your thoughts. Five years from now, when you are sitting in my shoes for example, this will be so clear to you. After all, what is an additional $30K in loans per month, per month?   eanuts, compared to all the money you will make in a great career lifetime…
That's the key my friend. Hope this helps dude, and good luck!
-- by 会员 JonFrank (2011/3/6 2:09:28)
Jon Thanks a million for your generous help and honest words! You've saved me from the dangerous mindset. I understand your position about goting to the best school as I can get into. Now here comes another question - how to define the 'best'? As you said earlier, JHU is a big name and I also believe it is very potential in growing to a tob bschool someday in the future, which will probably foster my career development? On the other hand, CMU is ranked top16, a postion that is not too high or too low, making JHU appear more attractive (since JHU is ranked higher than CMU though JHU's MBA program is very new). As a result, I have no idea about making a final decision between CMU and JHU. Joe -- by 会员 snailc (2011/3/6 13:26:37)
Joe, it's a great question. And it will take some research (on both our parts) to determine it. Both of these schools are comparable from a reputation standpoint (although in the US anyway, JH's MBA program is much less well known than that if CM). Remember, JH is highly rated, but its MBA program is not.
But so now, we start to look at the other factors. Reaching out to alums to determine how they are doing this year with jobs, gauging the personality of the school, etc. Do you want to stay in the US? Which school has a better reputation in China, more alums, etc.? Who offers more exciting classes in your field of choice? I believe I know the answers to all these questions my friend, but I want you to come to them on your own. : )
Still, you can start that work now (doing that research).
But the first step of course would be...to get into CM first. : )
Jon Frank
|
|