GWD1-Q39 对前人解答的疑惑~~

alpaca

Which of the following most logically completes the passage below?

Heavy rains during Centralia
’s corn planting season prevented some farmers there from planting corn.It is now the planting season for soybeans, another of Centralia’s principal crops, and those fields originally intended for corn are dry enough for planting.Nonetheless, even though soybean prices are unusually high at present, the farmers will leave most of these fields empty rather than plant them with soybeans, since ??????.

A.the extensive rains have led to an increase in the price of corn

B.some Centralian farmers anticipate serious financial losses due to the extremely wet spring planting season

C.chemicals that were used to prepare the fields for corn planting would stunt the growth of soybeans

D.the majority of Centralia

’s corn farmers were able to plant corn as they had intended, despite the wet planting season

E.many Centralian farmers grow both corn and soybeans

答案是C



看到前人在解释帖里说：
用LAYWER的方法:
7.RESOLVE THE PARADOX
看原文：找出原文的矛盾或奇怪的现象
找答案：用相关无关排除答案，和具体的矛盾的事有关无关，结合TEST。
TEST：答案必须使原文相矛盾的事物不矛盾或都是真，都成立
看原文：原文无结论,是说RAIN中种CORN,无RAIN种SOYBEAN.但无人中SOYBEAN.
找答案：就是找和SOYBEANh和CORN有关系,而且同时出现的选项 -解释人们种CORN但不种SOYBEAN。
TEST： A,B,D中无SOYBEAN ,排除,
       E中提及了CORN 和SOYBEAN,但是没有解释矛盾.
       C中提及了CORN 和SOYBEAN, 也解释矛盾,正确选项.



可是我怎么觉得这种解释不太对呢？
我觉得原文的矛盾在与到了种soybean的季节（也就是应该重soybean了）可是人们宁愿空着地也不愿意种soybean。我觉得这里的corn只是一个背景因素，因不是解题的关键啊……


我这样想对吗？请NN给我指点一下思路吧~

alpaca

期盼NN解答……

queenie924

种corn是前提条件啊~~题目说现在是种soybean的季节~种corn是这个季节之前的事情~

过去对现在有了一个作用~

过去：那些农民没有种corn，但本来是准备种的~而这些准备种corn的东西就接下来影响了再在这里种soybean

anqi_ren

and those fields originally intended for corn are dry enough for planting
是说这些地原来是种CORN的 但是因为干燥可以种大豆。土地干燥只是一个方面，种豆对土地还有chemicals的要求（这个是从选项推策）....我觉得并不是到了季节就种大豆这么理解.....原文没说到季节这个因素吧....
不知道LZ觉得可以不？

lu80

我到觉得一下这个帖子可以作为LAYWER的补充，http://forum.chasedream.com/GMAT_CR/thread-419325-1-1.html?SearchText=GWD1 Q39

onlysilence222

C也有问题啊，如果是因为chemical的限制，chemical应该对所有土地都是一样的影响，那不是应该所有种玉米的土地都不能种大豆么？不懂不懂不懂。。。。。

醒醒Shine

onlysilence222 发表于 2011-10-7 14:31
C也有问题啊，如果是因为chemical的限制，chemical应该对所有土地都是一样的影响，那不是应该所有种玉米的 ...

这里原题没有讨论到是不是所有呀
since接的是premise的内容，一定要同时能attack因和果