请教HEC和INSEAD哪个好

Deboisseu

在论坛里逛了很久，发现大家似乎都更喜欢INSEAD,把INSEAD放的位置很高。但是佰度欧洲商学院，排名第一的却是HEC. 到底哪个学校更好，我问过很多法国朋友，所有人都知道HEC,认为是法国最好的商学院，不少人并不知道 INSEAD。总的来说，INSEAD注重职业化教育，MBA 很好，但是HEC的master是强项，更学术，而且在欧洲享有盛名。两者不能说说更好。
但是，我看到论坛里的很多排名，INSEAD都是第一，ＨＥＣ只是第二梯队。请问这种说法是不是有根据？　
HEC和INSEAD到底谁更好？ 求正解！

englandrocks

法国南特audencia有人有兴趣吗，今年10月开学的，要gmat，gre都考过了的。750分以上gmat的有奖学金。
适合现在想马上出去读MBA的。
面试在上海。有意加zoejyq(A) hotmail.com(msn)

YuCongyun

所属系统不一样，无法比较。从国际知名度上来说，Insead毫无悬念胜出。

yinxiaoxiao

光华中欧都轮不到学生

Happy2007

法国南特audencia有人有兴趣吗，今年10月开学的，要gmat，gre都考过了的。750分以上gmat的有奖学金。
适合现在想马上出去读MBA的。
面试在上海。有意加zoejyq(A) hotmail.com(msn)

-- by 会员 englandrocks (2010/7/29 12:25:40)

想问一句。。。真有人考完gmat又考gre么？
想知道他的心路历程。。。

ToughtoTouch

INSEAD TOP 2 IN EU
HEC      TOP 5 IN EU

INSEAD OVER HEC INTERNATIONALLY WHILE HEC BEYOND INSEAD IN GLOBAL FRENCH WORLD.

NOTE: ABOVE ONLY REFER TO MBA PROGRAM RATHER THAN M.S AND/OR GRANDE ECOLE . HEC IS CONSISTENTLY CLAIMED AS THE NO.1 BUSINESS SCHOOL IN EUROPE AS A WHOLE.

mlchina

在荷兰的银行里。Insead是几乎人尽皆知的。而HEC几乎没人听说过。两者的名气上区别极大（在法国以外）。

felix_zheng

自己好才是真的好，管别人怎么说呢 :-) ! 别人太多了，听不过来哦呵呵。

10个月的项目也不一定适合每个人；强大的咨询就业数据也不一定罩得住纯switchers（毕竟40%多的Top sponsonship和20-30% consultants from 2nd/3rd Tier)。理性地自我剖析make more sense吧。

ToughtoTouch

INSEAD TOP 2 IN EU
HEC      TOP 5 IN EU

INSEAD OVER HEC INTERNATIONALLY WHILE HEC BEYOND INSEAD IN GLOBAL FRENCH WORLD.

NOTE: ABOVE ONLY REFER TO MBA PROGRAM RATHER THAN M.S AND/OR GRANDE ECOLE . HEC IS CONSISTENTLY CLAIMED AS THE NO.1 BUSINESS SCHOOL IN EUROPE AS A WHOLE.

-- by 会员 ToughtoTouch (2010/7/30 3:53:10)

这个帽子扣大了。 恐怕还没有人能说自己是NO.1 BS IN EUROPE. 无论MBA还是M.S.

-- by 会员 zbb88 (2010/7/30 9:37:10)

Checking the methodology of the FT Rankings OVER YEARS with regard to QUALITY, FAME and SCALE of MS, MBA,EMBA, PHD, and tailored Professional trainings etc would help.  She actually covers full scope of advanced education EXCLUSIVELY in Business subjects.

Happy2007

INSEAD TOP 2 IN EU
HEC      TOP 5 IN EU

INSEAD OVER HEC INTERNATIONALLY WHILE HEC BEYOND INSEAD IN GLOBAL FRENCH WORLD.

NOTE: ABOVE ONLY REFER TO MBA PROGRAM RATHER THAN M.S AND/OR GRANDE ECOLE . HEC IS CONSISTENTLY CLAIMED AS THE NO.1 BUSINESS SCHOOL IN EUROPE AS A WHOLE.

-- by 会员 ToughtoTouch (2010/7/30 3:53:10)

这个帽子扣大了。 恐怕还没有人能说自己是NO.1 BS IN EUROPE. 无论MBA还是M.S.

-- by 会员 zbb88 (2010/7/30 9:37:10)

Checking the methodology of the FT Rankings OVER YEARS with regard to QUALITY, FAME and SCALE of MS, MBA,EMBA, PHD, and tailored Professional trainings etc would help.  She actually covers full scope of advanced education EXCLUSIVELY in Business subjects.

-- by 会员 ToughtoTouch (2010/7/30 18:06:17)

这个排名争议向来多，我只举个最现实的例子。同样的硕士专业，能去JUDGE/SAID或LSE的，通常不会选HEC.

-- by 会员 zbb88 (2010/7/30 19:08:28)

这么选的肯定是中国人
我就知道好多人放弃LSE去HEC
牛剑本科无以伦比，商科硕士就难说
看英法学生论坛
LSE vs HEC是个长盛不衰的话题