OG12-88

jenny1989117

Businesses are suffering because of a lack of money available for developement loans.To help businesses, the government plans to modify the income-tax structure in order to induce individual taxpayers to put a larger portion of their incomes into retirement savings accounts ,because as more money is deposited in such accounts, more money becomes abailable to borrowers.
which of the following, if ture, raises the most serious dout regarding the effectiveness of the government't plan to increase the amount of money available for development loans for businesses?
A when levels of personal retirement savings increase, consumer borrowing always increases correspondingly.
B The increased tax revenue the government would receive as a result of business explanation would not offset the loss in revenue from personal income taxed during the first year of the plan.
C Even with tax incentives,some people will choose not to increase their levels of retirement savings.
D Bankers generally will not continue to lend money to businesses whose prospective earnings are insufficient to meet their loan repayment schedules.
E The modified tax structure would give all taxpayers,regardless of their incomes,the same tax savingsfor a givenincrease in their retirement savings.
看了答案选择A但是觉得A也不太严谨跟C的严谨程度也差不多啊
不明白了
argument是说the money available for borrowers 增加就可以了....如果题目中指的是business borrowers（题中也没说清楚）那么，A还是有问题，总的钱数上升了，在business和consumer之间分配，也不一定business就不会增加啊？C 用了some，这两个选项不是都不一定么？为什么不能选C
请教高人！！！

jenny1989117

先自己顶一下吧，等了一下午都没有回复，是大家觉得太简单了么.........呜呜

SAGA5

UP 同LZ对A的想法一样

kudoucliff

呃……我感觉A就是说“消费者的钱被当成养老保险存起来了，那么可供消费者支配的钱就少了，那么消费者就会借更多钱来消费，可供贷款仍然供不应求”

xibao

up

sdcar2010

A uses ALWAYS = 100%.

C uses SOME = between 1-100%.

A weakens for sure.

xibao

为什么我的 回复 都没有提醒啊  我设置了 可是只能收到公共的提醒  对于我帖子的回复提醒根本没有  怎么回事啊？

husthaixiao

因为从题目中来看，放入养老保险账户中的钱不是由个人决定的，而是由政府操作的。所以C中说的情况是不存在的~~

ndslyy

我也觉得削弱程度一样啊。A是说会上升，可是你怎么看2个上升程度的比较啊？？？
C为什么some的人的力量就不足够大了呢？  A和C都有问题啊

wodexuefei

回答这题要明白美国的文化背景。在美国，公司贷款有很多途径，可以去银行或别的金融企业借钱，也可以自己发股份。这些款项的来源，是一般人的存款与投资。这题就是说，政府要让这些存款与投资增加，所以让纳税人可以免税存钱或是投资。A 指出这不一定会让公司有更多钱来借，因为那些纳税人看到自己的积蓄多了，也就去借更多的钱。