请教一题目OG249

hougang

以下是引用Tiangel在2004-8-15 17:36:00的发言：

想知道B. influenced generations of bluegrass artists, also inspired many musicians, including Elvis Presley and Jerry Garcia, whose music differed significantly from  到底是修饰musicians or artists?

个人意见觉得还是应该修饰many musicians，不知对否，请指教，谢谢~

Both of you are right, because Tianwan is from the prospective of Choice C, while you are from the prospective of Choice B. That is the difference. According to correct grammar expression, that in C illogically modifies the artists. Therefore C is not the correct answer. Tianwan is just to explain why it is wrong.

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-11-19 16:52:52编辑过]

welkin

以下是引用kurtzhou在2004-10-15 16:45:00的发言：

非常同意tianwan的观点，杨鹏难句教程里有个经典句子就是这种用法，贴出来供大家参考

One such novel idea is　that (idea) of inserting into the chromosomes of plants discrete genes that are not a part of the plants’ natural constitution：specifically，the idea of inserting into　　nonleguminous plants the genes，if they can be identified and isolated，that fit the leguminous plants to be hosts for nitrogen-fixing bacteria. Hence，(there is ) the intensified research on legumes。

that clause修饰the genes,"if they can be identified and isolated"被两个comma隔开是插入语。

gmat sc中有这种用法吗？ 如果有那是限定还是非限定啊？ 请nn指点！

顺便问问， 结构 sb1, including sb2 and sb3, who... 这时who指代的是那个啊？是不是非限定呢？ 请大家多多咱指点

welkin

up

Avantasia

指代sb1

welkin

再次感谢 Avantasia 版主。 那如果是指代sb1， 那此时是是不是非限定呢？ 如果要表示限定的说法，是不是只能改为 sb1 who.... ，including sb2 and sb3 呢？这种说法会产生歧义吗？

weichenli

是限定吧! including sb 2 and sb3 插入句?

open to discussion

weichenli

没有NN?

who 是邻近指代吧? 我想还是要看句意跟谓语的单复数来往前决定要修释的SB

up up

weichenli

总像是再跟自己讲话似的

做个总结吧!

由于That 不可用于非限定, 他前面的逗号会造成前面的句子变成插入句

WHO 可以有非限定用法, 所以要由WHO后面的谓语判断

yulimeng

我也总结

1.that 不能用于非限定修饰。

2.本句结构 many musicians + 介词引导插入语 + whose 引导的定于从句

wsdoll

choice C 中 that.... 修饰的是 musician.