(急)新人求助，关于论文发表和申请美国PHD..请大家帮帮忙吧，真的太着急了: (

tianding827

呵呵,你误会了,我没较真,只是第一次听到这么个说法,想既然有这个说法,肯定不是你自己瞎叫的,应该是比较公认的叫法.

JM也就是唬唬外行吧,top10评tenure基本没几个把jm算A的,但management science对于modeling的人说,到哪里都算,而且top的学校觉得发management science比JMR好.

-- by 会员 xiaopanghu (2010/4/3 14:55:15)

JM没那么衰吧……LS是说的Journal of Management 还是 Journal of Marketing ? Journal of Marketing前些时候可是所有商科类学术期刊里被引用率最高的一个（ISI Web Knowledge, 2007）

xiaopanghu

还有journal of managemen这么个杂志???

不是说jm不好, 要讲managerial implication哪个能跟jm比?但是你看top学校哪有纯粹作strategy的人?哪个job market star是做strategy的?

zzmypster

我看AMA每年统计的A journal requirements原来最早是六个（那四个+JR,IJRM）后来把后俩去掉，只剩前四个了。这个估计还是比较公认的。不过我确实很少读到JM的paper，感觉其的确偏重managerial，作为Academia大多还是读JMR、JCR，MktS略多于MgtS。MgtS当然是非常好的journal，但就像Econmetrica、AER一样，不怎么算marketing A journal。

jangle

貌似quant的牛人都喜欢发Marketing Science, Management Science, JMR
CB的牛人喜欢发JMR, JCR, JPSP, JESP, OBHDP, JCP
JM确实比较特殊
非常同意xiaopanghu的看法

vickyhua

谢谢大家的帮忙，你们的意见对我来说真的很有帮助。
看来CD的热心人真的很多。

brika

For top20, even for all the top 30, JM is not regarded as A journal. Management Science definitely is A journal.

Peter Golder(just transfers to Tuck from Stern) is a strategy guy and you can see some of his publication from Marketing Science and JMR, and one of his Ph.D students who also works some projects on strategy will graduate this year with a top journal paper published.

boum

Management Science 被IS和SCM的人看成是A journal

xiaopanghu

不绝对，有些top20的学校因为有纯粹作strategy的牛人，jm也算，比如umd阿什么的。

palamo2008

This is very different from what I learnt. At least in our university(Ranking around 30), JM is the main stream mktg journal, so any research field with good managerial implications might get in. However, JCR, JMR and MKTGS all have specialities. Therefore JM is the No. 1 in MKTG.