prep1-32没问过

ilovesony4

State spokesperson:  Many businesspeople who have not been to our state believe that we have an inadequate road system.  Those people are mistaken, as is obvious from the fact that in each of the past six years, our state has spent more money per mile on road improvements than any other state.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously undermines the reasoning in the spokesperson's argument?

Which of the following, if true, most seriously undermines the reasoning in the spokesperson's argument?

(A) In the spokesperson's state, spending on road improvements has been increasing more slowly over the past six years than it has in several other states.

(B) Adequacy of a state's road system is generally less important to a businessperson considering doing business there than is the availability of qualified employees.

(C) Over the past six years, numerous businesses have left the spokesperson's state, but about as many businesses have moved into the state.

(D) In general, the number of miles of road in a state's road system depends on both the area and the population of the state.

(E) Only states with seriously inadequate road systems need to spend large amounts of money on road improvements.

。。

E一开始想选但觉得貌似太狠了，我想问D为什么不对，它这样是说路的数量要看人口和地区，那不是就说钱投的多不代表ADEQUATE吗~~算推理过渡吗~~~

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-5-31 15:36:03编辑过]

zzzzzz88

我也很不明白啊 这个问题中reasoning是指 原文第一句话么 我觉得应该对“sopkensperson 认为商人不来我们州市因为我们道路系统差”进行削弱啊  所以应该价格别的原因  所以认为 c和d都可以呀

e有点没道理

谢谢NN指点啊

lollypp

这题没有明显的因果关系，只是讲路不好，和花钱修路，找他因有点困难，很容易无关。

文中说商人不来是因为我们路不好，作者反对这个观点，拿“我们花了很多钱”修路在支持他的观点：商人不是因为我们的路不好而不来的。那么E是很好的断桥削弱：因为你花大价钱修路，正是说明你的路不好。反驳了作者的观点。

Ailsa灵幽幽

支持E~   是因果倒置吧

moon皎洁

那为什么b不可以选？？说商人不来这个州不是因为路的关系~