[求助关于GAMC出题思路prep-90

我要飞

90.   (25002-!-item-!-188;#058&001132)

 

X:  In order to reduce the amount of plastic in landfills, legislatures should impose a ban on the use of plastics for packaging goods.

Y:  Impossible!  Plastic packaging is necessary for public safety.  Consumers will lose all of the safety features that plastic offers, chiefly tamper-resistant closures and shatterproof bottles.

Which of the following best describes the weak point in Y's response to X's proposal?

A. Y ignores the possibility that packaging goods in materials other than plastic might provide the same safety features that packaging in plastic offers.

B. The economic disadvantages of using plastics as a means of packaging goods are not taken into consideration.

C. Y attempts to shift the blame for the large amount of plastic in landfills from the users of plastic packaging to the legislators.

D. Y does not consider the concern of some manufacturers that safety features spoil package appearances.

E. Y wrongly assumes that X defends the interests of the manufacturers rather than the interests of the consumers.

正确答案：A

我知道CDE都不对，也不否认A对，为什么不能选B呢？

为什么否定Y不可以通过说他只看到了有用的一面被抛弃了，而忽视里副作用也被摒弃了呢？

jiaojiao1426

题目要求是指出Y的WEAKNESS。B当中出现的新概念是无关的内容

而A选项明确的指出了Y逻辑错误.认为plastic  package 是一个必要条件。曲解了X的意图

wyxpark

"best" answer

因为Y考虑的是safety原因，B也有道理，但是在Y提出的safety上面直接否定他，就是best answer

我要飞

谢谢，哈哈，好开心啊