以下是引用天蝎座1107在2009-4-18 23:53:00的发言:上语法题 请大家解答C为什么对 新prep1-194 Whereas the honeybee’s stinger is heavily barbed and cannot be retracted from the skin, because the yellow jacket has a comparatively smooth stinger, it is therefore able to be pulled out and used again. A. because the yellow jacket has a comparatively smooth stinger, it is therefore able to be pulled out and used不能说be able to be有能力被 错 应该用can not be/could not be B. the comparative smoothness of the yellow jacket’s stinger allows them to pull it out and then can therefore use it这里them指代错误 and then can therefore use的主语the comparative smoothness不能发出use这个动作 C. the yellow jacket’s stinger is comparatively smooth, and can therefore be pulled out and used D. in comparison, the yellow jacket’s stinger is smooth, and thus able to be pulled out and used这里in comparison多余 因为whereas已经有了对比的意思 able to be done错 E. in comparison, the yellow jacket has a smooth stinger, thus allowing it to be pulled out and used错在in comparison多余
这里我不明白的是C选项 逗号+and后面不是应该完整的句子么 难道是省略了与前面相同的主语yellow jacket's stinger么 但至少也应该用and it can therefore be pulled out and used啊 我觉得这里主语不能省略 至少要用个代词
如果C对的话 那么很多句子中的逗号+and后面都可以不用完整的句子了 很是困惑 请大家解答啊 哇~~有题~~我也要加入讨论~~ 我觉得根据三层次说,首先结构上whereas引导一个从句,后面应该出现主句,直接排除ADE,而且A得it指代有问题,如果划线句子是第二层次的主从句,it应该指代yellow ,但是这里明显是就近指代smooth stinger,所以有问题。 然后B得逻辑有致命错误,而且comparative smoothness of the yellow jacket’s stinger及其awkward,后面的and then can therefore也很awkward, then和therefore重复,而且用了太多代词看起来费脑子 C得表达方式jacket’s stinger is comparatively smooth明显优于B,省略主语是个常见相向,而且我发现prep里面好像从来没有因为省略主语就算错的,只有正确选项里出现省略主语的情况,所以感觉GMAC不把省不省主语作为一个大考点,反而他们会讨厌代词,因为还要判断只待前面什么东西,费脑子。 怀疑很可能是原文就是这么写的,他们精心设计了4各错误选项以后,读读原文还蛮顺口的也就懒得改了 |