GWD32-11 后天就考了,xdjm们帮忙看看

jonathan1987

:GWD32-Q11

Several ancient Greek texts provide accounts of people being poisoned by honey that texts suggest was made from the nectar of rhododendron or oleander plants. Honey made from such nectar can cause the effects the texts describe, but only if eaten fresh, since the honey loses its toxicity within a few weeks of being made. In Greece, rhododendrons and oleander bloom only in springtime, when they are the predominant sources of nectar.

 

Which of the following, if true, most strongly support the accounts of Greek texts?

 

A.      There are no plants that Greece in ancient times that produce more nectar than rhododendrons or oleanders does.

B.       In areas where neither rhododendrons nor oleanders grow, honey is never poisonous.
        

C.      A beebive’s honeycomb cannot have some sections that contain toxic honey and other sections that contain nontoxic honey

D.      The incidents of honey poisoning that are related in the ancient texts occurred in the springtime or in the early
        summer

E.       Whether the honey in a beehive is toxic depends solely on which plants
        were the source of that was used to make the honey.

这题的答案是d, 

 但是我不理解的是b错在哪里了?

我觉得bd都对啊~~~~

水墨p

嗯～～我也想不通！！

哪位好心NN来解答～

rosyrosy00

B说的是蜜的产地，而原文说的是产蜜的时间。

如果其他地方不产这种有毒的蜜，但是这种蜜产在夏天秋天冬天，那还是support了作者而weaken了Greek texts了。

题目要求你support的是Greek texts，不是作者。

jonathan1987

Several ancient Greek texts provide accounts of people being poisoned by honey that texts suggest was made from the nectar of rhododendron or oleander plants.(这个是Greek texts 的内容,说明r和o会影响人们,使人们生病)
            Honey made from such nectar can cause the effects the texts describe, but only if eaten fresh, since the honey loses its toxicity within a few weeks of being made. In Greece, rhododendrons and oleander bloom only in springtime, when they are the predominant sources of nectar.这个应该是文章
    

背景. 

Which of the following, if true, most strongly support the accounts of Greek texts?

A.      There are no plants that Greece in ancient times that produce more nectar than rhododendrons or oleanders does.
            

B.       In areas where neither rhododendrons nor oleanders grow, honey is never poisonous.
            我觉得这是个很典型的无因无果型的

支持,也就是说没有这个r和o的话, 就不会用中毒的发生, 难道这个不是支持吗?

C.      A beebive’s honeycomb cannot have some sections that contain toxic honey and other sections that contain nontoxic honey

D.      The incidents of honey poisoning that are related in the ancient texts occurred in the springtime or in the early
        summer

d说中毒都是发生在春天或者是早夏, 我觉得d是支持了整个argunment,
            

E.       Whether the honey in a beehive is toxic depends solely on which plants
        were the source of that was used to make the honey.

因为问题问的是支持greek texts, 所以我觉得b更恰当, 如果问题问的是支持整个argunment的话,这时候我觉得就应该选d了

快来拍砖~~~~~

tiffany1102

up.

haoweibriony

我认为正确答案是D

Greek text的观点是毒honey是由the nectar of rhododendron or oleander plants造成的，如果象B所说，

B.       In areas where neither rhododendrons nor oleanders grow, honey is never poisonous. 只能证明毒honey和rhododendron or oleander plants有关，与nectar没关系了。