帮忙哦 找不出漏洞啊

queenie0308

Motorcycle X has been manufactured in the Us for 70 years.Although one foreign company has copied the motocycle and is celling it for less,the company has failed to attract motovyvle X customers---some say because its product lacks the exceptional loud noice made by motocycle X.But there must be some other explanation.Afterall,foreign cars tend to be quieter than similar American-made cars,but they sell at least as well.Also,television asvertisements for motocyce X highlight its durability and sleek lines,not its noiciness,and the ads typically have voice-over or rock music rather than engine-roar on the sound track.

rosyrosy00

Afterall,foreign cars tend to be quieter than similar American-made cars,but they sell at least as well----------cars和motorcycles的类比有问题。

television asvertisements for motocyce X highlight its durability and sleek lines,not its noiciness,-------正因为突出的是durability and sleek lines，所以它的noiciness很有可能确实不如X家的，如调查所说 lacks the exceptional loud noice made by motocycle X.

and the ads typically have voice-over or rock music rather than engine-roar on the sound track.------如果engine-roar 能轻易被voice-over or rock music 覆盖，更进一步说明了lacks the exceptional loud noice made by motocycle X。

这题没问题吧，怎么有人喜欢loud noise的？还是买摩托车的人就喜欢有loud noise？

我只找了这三点，而且2、3我觉得可以合成一段，可是找不到更多了，期待NN。。。

queenie0308

television asvertisements for motocyce X highlight its durability and sleek lines,not its noiciness,-------正因为突出的是durability and sleek lines，所以它的noiciness很有可能确实不如X家的，如调查所说 lacks the exceptional loud noice made by motocycle X. 没道理吧 这是在说X的广告啊

queenie0308

and the ads typically have voice-over or rock music rather than engine-roar on the sound track.------如果engine-roar 能轻易被voice-over or rock music 覆盖，更进一步说明了lacks the exceptional loud noice made by motocycle X。你理解错了吧 他一直在说X的广告啊啊

OnlyMarlboro

cars 和 motorcycle 一样么？作者没说出这个类比是一样的所以后面说cars的未必适用于解释motorcycle

作者的最后一句消费者买x是因为看了ads才买的吗？如果消费者不怎么看广告呢？那就算ads highlight了其他功能，对消费者来说还是没有什么影响

rosyrosy00

广告内容为什么不可以反驳？

广告很可能突出这个产品和其他相比有优势的A面，而忽略其他。但消费者却正是看重其他B方面呢？

queenie0308

问题是那个广告是X的广告 我没说广告内容不能反驳啊 当然能反驳 问题是你反驳的对象是谁？ X么？

queenie0308

恩 有道理 那是说消费者喜欢noice么？X的noiceness

queenie0308

帮帮忙哦 wa