法国女裁缝JJ求救！

jingchi

最后一题， GWD答案是A, JJ答案是B
我觉得答案明显是A啊
大家看看

GWD-13-Q19:
The author mentions the seamstresses’ view of guild membership as a “mark of independence from the patriarchal family” (lines 40-41) primarily in order to

A.    emphasize that the establishment of the seamstresses’ guild had implications that were not solely economic
B.    illustrate the conflict that existed between tailors and their female family members over membership in the tailors’ guild
C.    imply that the establishment of the seamstresses’ guild ushered in a period of increased economic and social freedom for women in France
D.    provide an explanation for the dramatic increase in the number of women working as seamstresses after 1675
E.    indicate that members of the seamstresses’ guild were financially more successful than were tailors’ female relatives protected by the tailors’ guild

qiqiaiwo

呵呵，gwd的本来就会有争议

再说这不是jj原题，不用担心

yinlixiao

我觉得答案是A.
这篇文章主要写的是男裁缝和女裁缝工会之间的矛盾，不是男裁缝和他的家庭的成员的矛盾。
illustrate the conflict that existed between tailors and their female family members over membership in the tailors’ guild。
单从选项来看，over membership in the tailors’ guild这部分就不对，their female family members是不可能属于the tailors’ guild， 文章也没有质疑过。 文章说的矛盾是，是否their female family members属于the seamstresses’ guild。

个人意见，可能不对，我也同时等待nn得出现。

jingchi

无所谓了，我也发现不是JJ原题。不过这道题答案肯定是A,因为GMAT最喜欢考的问题类型就是文中说一个说法，然后答案变相去重新阐述。这道题的上文有一句话，The conflict between
the guilds was not purely
economic, however.
所以正好是A重新阐述了一边这个观点。